- Joined
- Apr 3, 2004
- Messages
- 33,852
VS2 from EGL.
I1 from GIA
I1 from GIA
Last edited:
I am not a diamond grader so I have no precise answer.
But,,I have a feeling that...
1: what I think the grade should be.
2: what the grade should be in a sane world
3: what the grade actually is
Are 3 different things.
GIA - Si2
EGL - Si1
IGI - Vs2
HRD -I1
-C4C
my money is on I1
When are you going to tell us?
Remember that it's not possible to accurately grade clarity from a photo- and in real life, we'd be examining BOTH sides of the stone.
Based on the pic, if there's nothing else we can't see, it looks to be borderline SI2-I1.
The fact Garry's using is as a test case leads me to believe there's something wrong with the grade......
Does this help?
Close enough to the end that I can now post my thoughts.Just one day to go - you can change your vote or have another
GIA SI2
AGS I1
EGL SI1
I have the identical vote.