Diamond Clarity: Everything You Need To Know

Diamond Clarity – Basics

Diamonds in the top five categories all have identical clarity to the naked eye. The takeaway? This important C presents an opportunity to stretch your budget. 

Diamond clarity - rarity or budget friendly?

PriceScope Pointer: The most purchased clarity grades are VS1, VS2 and “eye clean” SI1. Learn how to define and find a diamond that’s eye-clean just below.

Before going on: Check out the PriceScope Diamond Buying Guide

Basics-1

Diamond Clarity Described

The world’s natural diamonds formed between 1-3 billion years ago, 100 miles beneath the earth’s surface. As they grew, chemicals and elements present in the earth became trapped within their crystal lattices. Clarity evaluates a gemstone’s relative freedom from such internal characteristics, classified as inclusions, and from surface characteristics, classified as blemishes.

grading chart
Image courtesy of IGI
  • A gemstone with no characteristics visible at 10 power magnification, is considered flawless (FL), and a gemstone with surface blemishes but no inclusions can be graded internally flawless (IF).
  • A stone with minute characteristics, difficult to find even at 10 power, is Very Very Slighty included (VVS). VVS1 is closest to flawless, followed by VVS2, which is still quite rare.
  • A stone with minor characteristics seen at 10 power magnification, is Very Slightly included (VS), also divided into VS1 and VS2.
  • A stone with characteristics noticeable at 10 power is Slightly Included (SI), divided into SI1 and SI2.
  • And finally, stones with characteristics large or abundant enough to be obvious at 10 power magnification, and possibly without magnification, are Included (i). Divided into i1, i2 and i3.

 

Basics-2 | Eye-Clean

Let’s get practical

“Eye-Clean” Definition

Set aside the 10 clarity grades for a moment: Many people just want an “eye-clean” diamond, meaning one which has no inclusions invisible to the naked eye. There is no laboratory definition for this, but a PriceScope survey of gemologists resulted in this consensus:

Eye-Clean: No inclusions visible to the unaided eye when viewed from the face up position in daylight equivalent or fluorescent lighting between 6-12 inches from the eye using 20/20 vision.*

* Ask your vendor for their specific definition.

Eye clean diamond
Photo courtesy of PS member Soxfan

Great news! When graded by a top-tier laboratory, loose diamonds with VS2 clarity and higher are reliably eye-clean. Even better? You can frequently find diamonds with SI1 clarity which are eye-clean. It’s rare, but sometimes you might even find an SI2 diamond which meets the definition.

Eye Clean Clarity Grades

When graded according to strict, internationally accepted standards:

high ranges

low ranges

How do I know a diamond is eye-clean?

  • Any diamond with VS1 clarity and higher should be eye-clean.
  • Round brilliant diamonds VS2 clarity and higher should be eye-clean (with rare exceptions).
  • SI1 and SI2 diamonds may have visible inclusions. The degree of visibility varies. There is no way to know if an SI1 or SI2 graded diamond is eye-clean based on a video or photograph.
  • Some PriceScope vendors indicate when an SI1 or SI2 diamond is eye-clean – by their definition – on the diamond’s detail page.

You can find eye-clean diamonds online right now: Some of our vetted vendors provide this analysis. Check out these reliable eye-clean definitions from James Allen and Whiteflash. Contact them now, and tell them you learned about “eye-clean” on PriceScope.

Analogy

Context Warning

The photos and videos sellers post online for diamonds are heavily magnified. The average 1.00 carat diamond is only as wide as the eraser on the back of a small pencil. Keep that in mind when analyzing clarity in those images, along with the clarity plot on the grading report – which is only a map, not an indication of inclusion size.

PRACTICAL ANALOGY: 4K HD and Pores

Grading reports indicate where diamond clarity characteristics are, but give no scale. Sometimes an inclusion on a clarity plot can look big and scary, but that inclusion might be completely transparent and invisible. Online diamond videos and photos are great to have, but they can show diamonds at a huge scale, frequently at far higher magnifications than they were graded. This is like zooming into someone’s face on 4K HD television. When you see someone’s cheek stretched across a 60-inch screen you can literally see every pore. But in real life, you’d never see a person like that.

Girl's cheek at distance and then highly magnified
Diamond clarity chart analogy

Basics-3

Real world information

Unlike carat weight, which is standardized, color and clarity grading are subjective human estimations. Moreover, some laboratories have softer standards than others: The diamonds seen in many chain stores, malls and discount outlets have observable tint at higher grades, unlike diamonds sent to top-tier laboratories. This can give shoppers a false and negative first impression about warmer color.

mall standards

  • Diamond clarity grading is a subjective judgment
  • Standards also vary, so diamonds graded VS1 or VS2 in a chain store might be judged SI1 at GIA or AGS
  • Undisclosed issues can exist beyond 10x magnification, as we will cover below.

Basics-4

Can I choose clarity online with confidence?

YES.

Successful online sellers like our recommended PriceScope vendors, have methods of reliably classifying and communicating diamond clarity, whether you’re examining it in-person or purchasing online. They also offer liberal inspection periods and free returns so you can make your purchase with complete confidence.

  1. Start with diamond grading reports: Diamonds over 0.25ct should come with a full report (or certificate) issued by a gemological laboratory. Color and clarity grading are subjective so tolerances among labs vary – even between a single lab’s various locations – but the accepted standard among reputable institutions is +/- one grade.

PriceScope Pointer: GIA, AGS, IGI and GCAL all grade loose diamonds with strict, reliable standards. Read more about these laboratories on our diamond certification page.

  1. Ask for photos and videos: First things first. Camera and monitor settings make diamonds look different screen to screen, so you can’t make nuanced decisions with images. With that said, videos and images are useful. And when a seller’s in-house images are consistently made, in one setup, then head-to-head comparisons within that seller’s inventory are practical.
  1. Ask the seller directly: If you have questions beyond what a diamond grading report and supplemental videos and images can communicate, pick up the phone, chat or email and get in touch with the vendor. It’s in their best interest to communicate transparently with you. After all, they don’t want the expense of shipping a diamond, only to have it returned on their dime as well.

Get fast answers to any question: Ask our community of unbiased independent helpers.

Ready to find your diamond?


Intermediate Diamond Clarity

Analysis

A diamond’s clarity grade and appearance can be influenced by many factors, beginning with five gemological considerations considered by graders, as well as the diamond’s shape, carat weight and – importantly – factors beyond 10x magnification which may go unreported.

Analysis-1 | Factors

Other Factors Considered

In addition to visibility at 10 power magnification, gemologists also consider Location, Number, Color, Size and the Nature of inclusions and blemishes when deciding the diamond clarity grade.

Five Other Considerations

five additional factors
Diamond clarity chart considerations

1. Location

An inclusion’s location in the diamond can influence many things. Visually, an inclusion in the center of the diamond may be reflected by other facets, making it seem to appear in many places. Alternately, if the same inclusion is located near the girdle (edge) the clarity grade will be impacted less. Certain inclusions types which are completely benign when enclosed in the crystal may pose a threat to durability if they reach the surface. If there is any such threat the clarity grade will be lowered.

2. Number

A diamond with a single iteration of an inclusion type is impacted less than a diamond with numerous iterations of that inclusion. Similarly, a diamond with a single inclusion type may be impacted less than a diamond with many inclusion types. When judging clarity this works hand in hand with the nature of the inclusions (described below).

3. Color

When a grader analyzes clarity the inclusions can be transparent, white, black or certain other colors. When a diamond’s inclusions are completely transparent the clarity grade will be impacted less than a diamond with opaque inclusions.

4. Size

In grading clarity the size of an inclusion matters, especially when considering its impact on the diamond as a whole. Logically, the larger an inclusion, the more influence it has on the clarity grade.

PriceScope Pointer: A diamond which has several tiny inclusions may be more desirable, in an eye-clean sense, than a diamond with a single large inclusion – which may be more visible.

5. Nature

In terms of clarity, the nature of an inclusion weighs how it may impact durability as well as visibility. A break within the stone may pose a durability risk, depending on its size and location, and the diamond’s clarity grade will be adjusted accordingly. Alternately the nature of a pinpoint is always perfectly benign.

Summary

The location, number, size, color and nature of all internal and surface characteristics are considered together when establishing the final clarity grade.

PriceScope Pointer: Clarity characteristics which pose any risk to durability whatsoever will always be lowered to the I2 or I3 clarity grades. With that said, even the most flawless diamond can chip if struck the wrong way. For this reason, no different than your automobile, we recommend insuring your diamond jewelry.

Analysis-2 | Shapes

Inclusions are more visible in certain shapes.

In grades VS1 and below inclusions may be more visible in certain fancy shapes than they are in round brilliants. This is particularly true of emerald cuts and square-emerald cuts because their facets are longer, broader and more transparent.

  • Round brilliants: The brilliant facets and contrast pattern mask some inclusions.
  • Princess, radiant, oval, pear, marquis and hearts may show inclusions at corners and tips more readily than in the center.
  • Step cuts like emerald and square-emerald cuts have long, flat facets which are more transparent and reveal inclusions more.

Different diamond shapes

Analysis-3 | Size

Inclusions become more visible at larger carat weights.

As diamonds increase in carat weight the inclusions present become more visible. Remember, the diamond’s clarity grade is based on how noticeable its clarity characteristics were when viewed at 10 power magnification, whether it weighs 0.25 carats or 2.50 carats.

  • Diamonds with FL, IF, VVS1 or VVS2 clarity should remain perfectly clean to the naked eye at any carat weight.
  • Diamonds with VS1 clarity should remain eye-clean at any weight, but it’s prudent to verify for round-brilliant diamonds weighing 4.00 carats or more and fancy-shapes weighing 3.00 carats or more.
  • Diamonds with VS2 clarity may show eye-visible inclusions as weight increases. It’s prudent to verify that a VS2 diamond is eye-clean at any weight, but particularly for diamonds weighing 2.00 carats or more.
  • SI1 and SI2 diamonds may have eye-visible inclusions. The degree of visibility varies, and the chance of eye-visible inclusions increases as diamond weight increases. It’s recommended to consult with the seller regarding the visibility of inclusions in any SI diamond.

Get help on clarity from our vetted vendors: Proven sellers like Blue Nile specialize at listening and helping you determine which combo of the 4Cs is perfect for you – and nicely in budget. Call or chat now, and get help today.

Analysis-4 | Undisclosed

Be aware of undisclosed haze, clouds, etc.

Are you seeing diamonds which seem inexplicably low priced? There are a few reasons this might be the case. One of them is a subtle or not-so-subtle brown, grey or green undertone having to due with its color appearance. Another may have to due with the undisclosed clarity issues described below. The endgame here is to always ask the seller why the diamond is discounted so much, but let’s arm you with some facts first.

A. “Clouds not shown” versus “Clarity grade based on clouds not shown.”

In clarity categories VS2, SI1, SI2 and below the comments “clouds not shown” or “additional clouds not shown” typically indicate the diamond grader considered them a non-issue. The comment is simply on the record for other gemologists who may examine the diamond later.

The comment “clarity grade based on clouds not shown” is a different matter. It indicates that the included pinpoints (clouds) were so widespread throughout the diamond that the grading category was determined by their presence, alone.

B. Haze beyond 10X magnification?

Since clarity grading is limited to 10X magnification characteristics beyond that scrutiny can go unreported. Haze is caused by large clouds of microscopic pinpoints when they become dense enough to interfere with light transmission and reduce transparency. Of course, clarity grading does not assess transparency. Occasionally a diamond with some level of haziness, caused by microscopic pinpoints, will pass through a grading laboratory with nothing disclosed on the report. This is because the pinpoints are not significant enough to merit attention when the diamond was analyzed at 10X magnification, but when taken collectively they still interfere with light transmission within the diamond. The resulting haziness can be very slight to severe.

“Sleepy stones”

Trade members refer to such hazy diamonds as being “sleepy,” a phenomenon which occurs on a sliding scale:

  • Slight cases may not even be noticed by the average jeweler but, when compared to other diamonds, the slightly-sleepy stone is less lively.
  • In moderate cases the diamond will seem to need a cleaning when seen in some lighting environments, but even the most thorough cloth-wiping or steam-cleaning won’t resolve the issue.
  • In the most severe cases the diamond is notably reduced in its performance qualities in all lighting environments.

This is not typically an issue in diamonds of VS2 clarity and above, but when a VS diamond’s price seems “too good to be true” this could be the reason. In all cases, thorough vetting by an experienced professional will detect the issue.

Where is this reported?

These issues are disclosed among traders. Wholesale suppliers are being asked to declare a diamond has “No BGM” (brown/green/milky) in business to business comments, but those notes are not typically passed on from diamond sellers to consumers.

Screen shot of wholesale search declaring "No BGM"

The world’s largest wholesale loose diamond trading platform has now added the ability to include or exclude “milky” diamonds (as a diamond clarity supplement) along with undertones of different shades, including brown, green and grey (as a diamond color supplement).

Screen shot of wholesale search with Milky and Shade options

The situation is fluid, complicated by assessment thresholds and resistance to disclose, from miner to supplier to retailer to shopper. Much of the wild variability in diamond pricing is attributable to undisclosed elements such as these.

What’s the solution?

  1. Revisit our advice above: Can I buy Diamond Clarity online with confidence?
  1. Start with diamond grading reports, look for seller-provided photos and videos, look for standardized imaging and, most importantly, ask the seller directly: If you have questions beyond what a diamond grading report and supplemental videos and images can communicate, pick up the phone, chat or email and get in touch with the vendor. It’s in their best interest to communicate transparently with you. After all, they don’t want the expense of shipping a diamond, only to have it returned on their dime as well.

Get fast answers to any question: Ask our community of unbiased independent helpers.

Ready to find your diamond?


Advanced Diamond Clarity

Evaluation-1

Taste Alert

Anything in this section can be overruled by personal taste and preference. Many people just want eye-clean clarity, but some have strong feelings about high-clarity and others go the opposite way, seeking low-clarities on purpose.

There are no “wrong” beliefs when it comes to clarity, but when making your decisions it will be useful to know the information below.

Diamond Clarity - Man and woman who don't seem to agree
Diamond clarity chart taste choices

Evaluation-2 | Philosophy

Clarity philosophies

There are a lot of preconceived notions about clarity. These may have to do with where someone grew up and what they learned about diamonds. Whatever the case, it’s a good idea to know how the wearer feels about diamond clarity and, in some cases, it may be enlightening to share this information with that person.

A. High clarity and bad information.

Many people are under the false impression that diamonds with higher clarity sparkle better. This is false. A diamond’s observable brightness, fire, sparkle and contrast are all attributable to its cut-quality. Diamonds with identical cut-geometry will sparkle identically at Flawless, VVS, VS and clean SI clarities. A diamond’s optical properties are not influenced by inclusions and blemishes, except in the very lowest grading category Included: (I1-I2-I3): Those three grades are reserved specifically for diamonds with inclusions numerous or severe enough to impact light transmission and/or durability.

B. High clarity and value.

Collection quality diamonds are those with color and clarity combinations which trade for the highest values and continue to hold that value best over time. Combining D, E, or F color with Flawless, Internally-Flawless, VVS1 or VVS2 clarity gives a diamond collection quality status in the eyes of diamond professionals and enthusiasts. Some people choose those combinations for this reason.

C. High clarity and symbolism.

Depending on culture and philosophy, diamonds may be seen as reflections of the relationships they symbolize. In such cases higher diamond clarity and color may be chosen, out of personal preference, to symbolize the perfection and purity of the union.

D. Low clarity and practicality.

Depending on culture and philosophy, a diamond’s inclusions may be considered birthmarks created by mother nature (or the lab-grown process) which make them unique and special. When inclusions are easily viewed with a loupe or are eye-visible without magnification it also makes the diamond quickly identifiable.

E. Low clarity and prong-ability.

A visible inclusion near the girdle (the edge of the diamond) may be what jewelers call “prongable” – meaning the inclusion can be covered with a prong when the diamond is set. This may be extremely positive for shoppers on a budget, as it can make a low clarity diamond “eye-clean.” Just be sure the inclusion being pronged isn’t one that could be expanded or fractured as pressure is applied in the setting process.

Evaluation-3 | Age

Clarity and age

GREAT NEWS for everyone 40-something and over. As humans age we are all subject to the effects of presbyopia. What’s presbyopia? Farsightedness caused by loss of elasticity of the lens of the eye. While that means you won’t be able to read what’s written on a dime any more it also means the small diamond inclusions you could barely spot in your 20s and 30s will now be invisible. Woo-hoo!

diamond clarity - senior couple happy and smiling

Get fast answers to any question: Ask our community of unbiased independent helpers.

Ready to find your diamond?


 

Scroll to Top