Diamond Buying Guide in 2024

Buying a diamond is a significant investment, and finding the perfect stone requires careful consideration of various factors, including the vendor. With a multitude of options available, it’s essential to choose a reputable vendor that offers quality diamonds and exceptional customer service. In this diamond buying guide, we’ll compare four top vendors: Whiteflash, James Allen, Blue Nile, and Adiamor. We’ll explore their offerings, policies, and services to help you make an informed decision.

Top 10 Reasons to Buy a Diamond

  1. Eternal Symbolism: Diamonds symbolize love, commitment, and endurance.
  2. Investment Value: Diamonds can retain and even increase in value over time.
  3. Unique Beauty: Each diamond is as distinct as the individual wearing it.
  4. Timeless Appeal: Diamonds never go out of style.
  5. Versatility: They can be incorporated into various jewelry designs.
  6. Durability: Diamonds are the hardest known natural substance.
  7. Rarity: Their scarcity adds to their allure.
  8. Sentimental Value: Diamonds mark cherished moments.
  9. Cultural Significance: Diamonds hold historical and cultural significance.
  10. Environmental Responsibility: Ethical sourcing is increasingly important.

Wondering which of the many diamond colors is best for you? Our elite list of vetted vendors like Whiteflash and James Allen are experts at listening and helping you determine which combo of the 4Cs is perfect for you - and nicely in budget. Contact Us and get help today.

What To Consider Before Buying A Diamond?

  • Determine Your Budget: Establish a clear budget for your purchase.
  • Identify the 4Cs: Understand the significance of Cut, Carat, Color, and Clarity.
  • Research Certification: Look for diamonds certified by reputable labs like GIA or AGS.
  • Define Your Priorities: Decide which factors matter most to you, be it size, quality, or budget-friendliness.
  • Explore Various Styles: Explore different diamond shapes and settings.
  • Research Vendors: Choose a trusted vendor like Whiteflash, James Allen, Blue Nile, or Adiamor.
Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE® Banner

Looking for quality diamonds without breaking the bank? A CUT ABOVE® is Whiteflash's exclusive collection of certified diamonds. Browse Whiteflash Diamond Range

How To Choose The Right Diamond Shape?

Diamond shape significantly impacts a diamond’s appearance. Consider the following popular shapes:

  • Round Brilliant: Classic and timeless.
  • Princess Cut: Square or rectangular with sharp corners.
  • Emerald Cut: Rectangular with step-cut facets.
  • Cushion Cut: Square or rectangular with rounded corners.
  • Marquise Cut: Elongated with pointed ends.
  • Pear Cut: A blend of round and marquise, resembling a teardrop.
  • Oval Cut: Elegance with an elongated shape.
  • Asscher Cut: Square with step-cut facets, similar to emerald cut.
  • Radiant Cut: Square or rectangular with brilliant-cut facets.

How To Choose The Right Diamond Carat Weight For Your Budget?

The Average Carat Size For An Engagement Ring

Image Source: James Allen

Balancing carat weight with your budget is essential. Consider these tips:

1. Prioritize Cut Quality:

  • Cut quality is a crucial factor in maximizing the visual appeal of your diamond. Well-cut diamonds reflect light effectively, making them appear larger than their carat weight suggests.

  • Opt for diamonds with excellent or ideal cut grades, as they will exhibit superior brilliance, fire, and scintillation, enhancing the overall appearance of the stone.

2. Opt for Slightly Smaller Carat Weights:

  • Instead of focusing on hitting exact carat weights, consider choosing a diamond slightly below whole numbers. For example, a 0.90-carat diamond can appear almost as large as a 1.00-carat stone but may be more affordable.
  • These slight variations in carat weight can result in significant cost savings while maintaining a visually appealing size.

3. Consider Specific Carat Weights:

  • Diamonds often experience price jumps at popular carat weights. For example, a 0.90-carat diamond may be significantly less expensive than a 1.00-carat diamond of similar quality.
  • Explore carat weights just below these milestones (0.90, 1.90, etc.) to find better value for your budget. The average carat weights for engagement rings typically range from 0.50 to 2.00 carats.

4. Understand Average Size Expectations:

  • Recognize that the perceived size of a diamond is influenced not only by carat weight but also by the diamond’s shape. Different shapes can make the diamond appear larger or smaller for the same carat weight.
  • For a round brilliant cut, the average size for an engagement ring is around 1.00 to 1.50 carats. Adjust your expectations based on the shape you prefer.

5. Explore Fancy Shapes:

  • Fancy shapes, such as ovals, marquises, and pear shapes, can offer a larger appearance for the carat weight. These shapes distribute the carat weight differently, providing a unique and elongated appearance.
  • If size is a priority, consider fancy shapes that may offer a larger look for the same carat weight compared to traditional round diamonds.

6. Focus on Overall Impact:

  • Remember that brilliance, sparkle, and overall visual impact are equally important as carat weight.
  • A well-balanced combination of cut quality, color, and clarity contributes to the overall beauty of the diamond, ensuring it captures attention and appears stunning regardless of the specific carat weight.

7. Set Realistic Expectations:

  • Understand that certain carat weights, such as 1.00 or 2.00 carats, are considered milestones and may have higher price points.
  • Be open to exploring diamonds slightly below these milestones to find the best balance between size and budget.

Why Does Diamond Cut Matter?

Diamond cut is crucial to a diamond’s sparkle and overall beauty:

  • Cut Quality Defines Brilliance: A well-cut diamond reflects light optimally.
  • Impact on Appearance: A superior cut can mask imperfections in other areas.
  • Importance of Proportions: Proper proportions ensure maximum light return.
  • Cut Grades: Look for diamonds with Excellent or Ideal cut grades for the best results.
Blue Nile Signature Ideal Diamonds Review

Image Source: Blue Nile

Where to buy Diamonds?

1. Whiteflash

Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE® Banner

Image Source: Whiteflash

Whiteflash is renowned for its precision-cut diamonds, known as A CUT ABOVE®. These diamonds are among the finest in the industry, offering exceptional brilliance and sparkle. Here’s what you can expect from Whiteflash:

Diamond Quality

Whiteflash’s signature A CUT ABOVE® diamonds are designed with unmatched precision for maximum light performance. They provide a wide range of GIA and AGS-certified diamonds, ensuring transparency and quality.


Whiteflash offers a wide range of engagement ring settings, and they excel in custom design. The “Dreams of Africa” collection features ethically sourced diamonds that support African communities.

Customer Service

Exceptional customer service with expert gemologists to assist you throughout the buying process. Lifetime trade-up and upgrade policies ensure long-term satisfaction.

Browse Whiteflash Diamonds

PriceScope’s 1-5 star ratings are categorical comparisons with the most thorough, consumer-focused online diamond and jewelry vendors, in categories, we believe reflect our experienced consumer community’s values. Check out PriceScope Jeweler Reviews

2. James Allen

James Allen is known for its vast inventory of diamonds and interactive 360-degree HD videos of each stone, allowing you to examine diamonds up close. Here’s what sets them apart:

Diamond Viewing

Their high-quality images and videos provide a detailed view of each diamond, enabling you to assess clarity and color with confidence. An extensive selection of lab-certified diamonds ensures diverse choices.

Customer Experience

A user-friendly website and dedicated customer service make the buying process straightforward. James Allen’s “Diamond Display Technology” allows you to virtually view diamonds before purchase.


Competitive pricing and a wide range of price points cater to various budgets. Frequent sales and promotions provide additional savings opportunities.

Browse James Allen Diamonds

3. Blue Nile

Blue Nile is a well-established online diamond retailer, known for its vast selection and competitive pricing. Here’s what you need to know about Blue Nile:

Extensive Inventory

Blue Nile offers a wide range of diamonds, including fancy shapes and rare stones. They also have their very own diamonds collection, Astor Their virtual gemologist tool assists in choosing the perfect diamond based on your preferences.

Pricing and Value

Competitive pricing and transparent diamond pricing charts help you make informed decisions. Blue Nile offers a “Build Your Own Ring” feature for customization.


Blue Nile’s educational resources, including guides and articles, are excellent for first-time buyers. Customer reviews and ratings provide insight into other buyers’ experiences.

Browse Blue Nile Diamonds

4. Adiamor

Adiamor is a family-owned business with a strong reputation for quality and customization. They offer a variety of settings and diamonds to suit different tastes and budgets:


Adiamor specializes in custom engagement rings and offers a range of design options. Their team of experienced jewelers can help bring your vision to life.

Quality Assurance

All diamonds are hand-selected and come with GIA or AGS certificates for quality assurance. The company is known for its commitment to ethical sourcing.

Warranty and Returns

Adiamor offers a 30-day return policy and a lifetime warranty on their jewelry, ensuring peace of mind. 

Browse Adiamor Diamonds

Comparison Summary

  • If you prioritize precision-cut diamonds and exceptional light performance, Whiteflash’s A CUT ABOVE® diamonds are a top choice.
  • For a vast selection with detailed imaging, James Allen’s 360-degree videos provide a comprehensive view of each diamond.
  • Blue Nile stands out for competitive pricing, extensive education resources, and user-friendly customization options.
  • Adiamor excels in customization, quality assurance, and ethical sourcing.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right vendor for your diamond purchase is crucial for a successful and satisfying experience. Each of the four vendors discussed here – Whiteflash, James Allen, Blue Nile, and Adiamor – offers unique advantages and caters to different preferences and budgets. Take your time to explore their offerings, read customer reviews, and utilize their educational resources to make an informed decision that suits your individual needs and preferences. Ultimately, the perfect diamond is a combination of quality, value, and personal preference, and with the right vendor, your dream diamond is within reach.

Scroll to Top