Help Appreciated: Our Diamond Finalist?

[julessd14]

Hi everyone!

My boyfriend and I have been researching/shopping for our forever diamond and wanted to get some second opinions on the following:

Diamond ($4,970): https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-di...i-color-si1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-7760854

GIA Report: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9T1YxUMTlnqc3ZTMm5vQUtTV1VSWDZUemlGTEd3M3VBOTBn/view?usp=sharing

Setting: https://www.jamesallen.com/engageme...um-15mm-comfort-fit-engagement-ring-item-8173

We asked for Idealscope images and the diamond is currently on hold for us while the images are being gathered (which we can share once received). Our budget for the diamond is <$5,500 for a 0.9+ ct. We care about attaining maximum sparkle (!!). We're looking for I-G color and SI1-VS1 clarity.

Thanks!

 

[mwilliamanderson]

It looks like you picked a good one. Hopefully the requested images confirm this!

 

[Rose-gold-or-bust]

Looks good! Very clean for an SI1

 

[sledge]

Appears you have done some homework. The proportions look promising. I would personally prefer a little steeper pavilion with the 34.5 crown, but it's still within acceptable range.

The IS image should confirm light performance.

By chance, did you ask JA about the feathers. That is the primary grade setting inclusion and I see you have several. Doubtful it's too problematic being an SI1 but I'd want to confirm no potential structural issues.

FYI, here is a screen cap of the HCA, in case you weren't already aware. Sorry, on my phone so had to do two captures to get it all.

 

[KKJohnson]

I think you picked an awesome stone and the only other one I would inquire about would be:

1.02 Carat round diamond

This 1.02 carat round diamond I color si1 clarity has Excellent proportions and a diamond grading report from GIA

www.jamesallen.com

JA makes it difficult to suggest options since the GIA report has to be requested in order to vet them.

 

[sledge]

JA makes it difficult to suggest options since the GIA report has to be requested in order to vet them.

If you see my eye twitching, it's because I'm doing all I can to not unleash on JA concerning their "cert policy".

Moving on.


Here is a super ideal from VC that hits your price, clarity and is a super ideal H&A stone. Comes with better upgrade program, and a discount on VC settings which are pretty stellar.

Victor Canera

victorcanera.com

This CBI stone is being crafted, which means it could be a smidge larger, better color or better clarity than it's being priced as. If it comes back better, you pay the same price. If it comes back worse, you get to walk or they adjust the price accordingly. Great upgrade program. Beautiful settings. And while I don't normally care for SI2's, HPD/CBI guarantees an EYE CLEAN stone.

https://www.hpdiamonds.com/en-us/diamonddetail/HPD10841

Last, but not least, here is an option from WF. It's a little below budget, but also below the 1 carat mark. It's part of their Expert Select program which is a near miss ACA, but comes with all the perks of an ACA.

Diamond | 0.908 ct I SI1 Expert Selection Round Cut Loose Diamond AGS Certified | 4068006

This fabulous 0.908 carat Round Ideal cut diamond has a clarity grade of SI1 and color grade of I.It is an excellent choice for engagement rings. | 4068006

www.whiteflash.com

 

[julessd14]

Thanks everyone! It's so helpful to know folks at the RockyTalky community are willing to share their expertise with us!

The Idealscope image came in from James Allen as follow. What are your thoughts?

Should we pull the trigger?

 

[julessd14]

I think you picked an awesome stone and the only other one I would inquire about would be:

1.02 Carat round diamond

This 1.02 carat round diamond I color si1 clarity has Excellent proportions and a diamond grading report from GIA

www.jamesallen.com

JA makes it difficult to suggest options since the GIA report has to be requested in order to vet them.

Thank you! You nailed it, having to start a conversation to get each GIA report has been one of the most tedious part!

 

[julessd14]

Appears you have done some homework. The proportions look promising. I would personally prefer a little steeper pavilion with the 34.5 crown, but it's still within acceptable range.

The IS image should confirm light performance.

By chance, did you ask JA about the feathers. That is the primary grade setting inclusion and I see you have several. Doubtful it's too problematic being an SI1 but I'd want to confirm no potential structural issues.

FYI, here is a screen cap of the HCA, in case you weren't already aware. Sorry, on my phone so had to do two captures to get it all.

Your message brought a smile to our face! We did a lot of research leading up to this so we're glad to hear we did an ok job at picking a diamond!

Could you help share a bit more on the "potential structural issues" please? We asked about the risk for chipping and was informed that shouldn't be a concern. I can certainly probe more though!

Thanks for the HCA score!

 

[doberman]

At SI1 I sincerely doubt you will have to worry about structural issues. My SI diamond has held up through the years. Looks like a great stone!

 

[sledge]

I agree that an SI1 should not cause structural issues. However, there are several feathers. One appears to reach from crown to pavilion side. It's free to ask JA's gemologist to review and confirm there are no potential issues, even if it's a minimal worry.

The IS image looks good btw.

 

[new-beginning]

but please keep in mind your original choice does not offer a great option if an upgrade would ever be a possibility.

 

[julessd14]

I agree that an SI1 should not cause structural issues. However, there are several feathers. One appears to reach from crown to pavilion side. It's free to ask JA's gemologist to review and confirm there are no potential issues, even if it's a minimal worry.

The IS image looks good btw.

Great point! We've emailed JA back to get this checked and confirmed, for piece of mind. Thank you for reviewing the IS!

 

[julessd14]

but please keep in mind your original choice does not offer a great option if an upgrade would ever be a possibility.

No upgrade possibilities

 

[julessd14]

At SI1 I sincerely doubt you will have to worry about structural issues. My SI diamond has held up through the years. Looks like a great stone!

That's awesome to hear! Thanks for sharing this detail about your SI with us!

 

[rockysalamander]

The JA stone is nice, but will require you to spend double if you upgrade. WF, VC and Highperformancediamonds much more generous policies.