Which would you choose for a 0.5c pendant

[confuzzl3don3]

Hi all,

Simple question. Looking to get a central diamond for a pendant for my fiance, and tossing up between these two. Price point similar. Both rank well on hca and enchanted diamonds cut score calculator.

1) E Si1 0.51c gia number 2298989143
No fluorescence (Check attachments)

2) E vs2 0.5c but with medium blue fluorescence. (Check attachments)

 

[david b]

I would choose the 0.51 E SI1, no Fluorescent, in this carat size VS2 and SI1 will look the same -clean to the naked eye

 

[confuzzl3don3]

I would choose the 0.51 E SI1, no Fluorescent, in this carat size VS2 and SI1 will look the same -clean to the naked eye

But it's a knot though, which may be more apparent on the surface? Is it mainly because of the medium blue fluorescence for you?