Which one to choose based from ASET scope?

[lkhosasi]

Hi guys, any feedback regarding these 2 diamond reports? Which one will you choose? Appreciate your kind feedback please.

 

[lkhosasi]

Which diamond will perform better?

 

[gm89uk]

About the same. What's more important here is the colour and size difference.

 

[lkhosasi]

About the same. What's more important here is the colour and size difference.

It is not about color or size, but more of the sparkle. I realized 0.826ct has all green light at the outer circumference whereas the 0.766 outer circumference contains more bluish color than green. Will that affect the sparkle and firey of the diamond itself?

 

[Matthews1127]

Based upon only the above info, I’m Team 0.826KVS1.
Performance is likely to be similar; cut grade is the same.
K is more clean, and has better spread. It will face up larger, and the cut will hide the color, a bit.
Without knowing the vendor, it’s difficult to advise you to move forward, unless an upgrade is not in your future.
Are you able to post videos? Have you secured these diamonds, and placed them on hold?

 

[seaurchin]

Not exactly what you asked but if going for a bargain color grade of J or K, I'd want to pair it with the bargain (but still nice) cut grade of SI1 rather than VS1, and maybe get a little bit larger stone that way while still keeping an ideal cut.

 

[tyty333]

Those asets are computer generated. IMO you looking for a level of analysis between the two that you cant really get. It would be better to
call the vendor, have them pull the two stones and talk you through them. You really need a pair of eyes on the stones that know what they're
looking for.

 

[lovedogs]

Those asets are computer generated. IMO you looking for a level of analysis between the two that you cant really get. It would be better to
call the vendor, have them pull the two stones and talk you through them. You really need a pair of eyes on the stones that know what they're
looking for.

This. Brian Gavin will pull the stones for you and help you compare. The computer aset isn't as detailed, and both are excellent stones. So it should come down to looking at video/pics of both.

 

[gm89uk]

Being BG the real aset will also probably not give any additional useful information. They are both likely precision cut.

 

[lkhosasi]

I will try ask them to compare these 2 stones.

 

[lkhosasi]

Not exactly what you asked but if going for a bargain color grade of J or K, I'd want to pair it with the bargain (but still nice) cut grade of SI1 rather than VS1, and maybe get a little bit larger stone that way while still keeping an ideal cut.

I can't get larger size stone than 0.826ct as I have my own setting that fits 0.8ct stone.

 

[lkhosasi]

Based upon only the above info, I’m Team 0.826KVS1.
Performance is likely to be similar; cut grade is the same.
K is more clean, and has better spread. It will face up larger, and the cut will hide the color, a bit.
Without knowing the vendor, it’s difficult to advise you to move forward, unless an upgrade is not in your future.
Are you able to post videos? Have you secured these diamonds, and placed them on hold?

I don't have the videos yet. I did ask them earlier, but I guess they are very busy due to a lot of new diamonds coming in to their inventory which still don't have all the videos, H&A image, ASET image.
I asked them to put on hold for K VS1 0.826ct because of cleaner inclusion compare with the 0.766ct.

 

[ringo865]

Your setting can hold certain specific dimensions. Weights, while specific, can have a range of dimensions. Also, it is possible that the head of your current setting could be changed to fit whatever diamond you like. Have you seen K colored diamonds in real life? I love them, but they are not icy white.

 

[lkhosasi]

Your setting can hold certain specific dimensions. Weights, while specific, can have a range of dimensions. Also, it is possible that the head of your current setting could be changed to fit whatever diamond you like. Have you seen K colored diamonds in real life? I love them, but they are not icy white.

Yes, I have 3 K colored diamonds, 0.5ct, 0.8ct and 1.7ct. I can’t see much tint on 0.5 and 0.8ct. But my 1.7ct K, I can see quite obvious yellow tint from the side.