Need help for these diamond

[kes98]

Hi all, I'm in the process of buying a pair of round diamond stud ear ring for my wife and need your opinions for the following diamonds.



Diamond 1 in H color VS2



Diamond 2 in H color VS2



Diamond 3 in G color VS2



Diamond 4 in G color VS2

All 4 diamonds are in 0.60 carat range and score under 2 in HCA and price difference between these are $200.
Please let me know which pair of diamonds would look the best or if you have any other better pairs in the price range of $4800
Thank you for all your help in advance.

 

[Gypsy]

Not #3. Post table depth and dimensions for each stone. Plus color in one place.

 

[kes98]

Thanks for your help. Here's more details on the stone

Diamond 1 - 0.608 carat in H color, VS2, Depth 61.8 Table 55.2 Crown angle 34.8 Pavilion angle 40.8 5.45x5.46x3.37
Diamond 2 - 0.601 carat in H color, VS2, Depth 61.7 Table 56.7 Crown angle 34.8 Pavilion angle 40.8 5.39x5.41x3.34
Diamond 3 - 0.608 carat in G color, VS2, Depth 61.9 Table 57.2 Crown angle 34.5 Pavilion angle 40.9 5.38x5.43x3.35
Diamond 4 - 0.603 carat in G color, VS2, Depth 61.8 Table 55.8 Crown angle 33.9 Pavilion angle 40.9 5.40x5.43x3.35

Diamond 1 & 2 cost $4830
Diamond 3 & 4 cost $4938

Let me know what do you all think is a better pair or any other options out there....

 

[tyty333]

Do you have real images of these stones? The H pair look very good. #3 (G) looks like it has some issues but wondering
how much it shows up in real life?

The H pair is really nice...very similar numbers.

 

[kes98]

Diamond 1


Diamond 2


Diamond 3


Diamond 4

Here's the picture of the diamond that was send to me.
Thanks

 

[diamondseeker2006]

All 4 diamonds are great. So you cannot really go wrong with either pair. Cost is almost the same. Are they all from the same vendor? Trade-in policies would matter to me. I'd also like to know the cut classification, as in, are any of these hearts and arrows (such as ACA) or are they all ideal cuts but not H&A?

 

[kes98]

Re: Need help for these diamond stud

Found another pair from WF, how are these compare to the one above. These are about $200 cheaper.

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/diamond-pairs-details.aspx?diamond1=3483192&diamond2=3577070

Thank you for everyone's opinion.

 

[Gypsy]

H pair gets my vote.