CADs are here - help needed please!

[emmy12]

I think so too. I’m not even sure I’ll request a wax model, I’ll probably just move forward. I hope I love it! If not, there’s always LT

I'm a measure twice, cut once person, so I'd always want to see the wax before approving it but that is my control freak talking hehe. It does looks like it's going to be perfect from the CADs, though!

 

[faded264]

I have a very similar ring design, except with rose cut diamonds instead of MRB. I’ll attach a picture. Your most recent CAD reminded me a lot of my ring.

I hope you love it!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

I have a very similar ring design, except with rose cut diamonds instead of MRB. I’ll attach a picture. Your most recent CAD reminded me a lot of my ring.

I hope you love it!

Oh that’s beautiful! Do you know the measurements of your stones or the overall diameter? My center is a .60ct so I’m trying to compare visually.

 

[Rfisher]

I had him modify the prongs to eliminate the outer ones. Inspiration from an antique piece I saw on Instagram.

I like the looks of it!

I’m no expert - with that being said - was always under the impression in antique settings like this, the prongs that you had removed had actually snapped/been worn away. With a few remaining in other areas. The ones that had remaining bits at that point looked more like tab prongs and the stones weren’t chipped but plenty of the stones with missing prongs were.
It looks like DKJ went ahead and enlarged the ‘v’ prongs, my question would be was that scaled up enough for the stones be secure in the long run. Again - the ones I’ve seen/had once those prongs wore away the remaining ‘v’ left the stone a bit wobbly.
I’m not saying DKJ would intentionally produce something unsecure.
Again - I have no proof that cluster rings like this weren’t ever intentionally made this way - just my impression of what I’ve seen.
Maybe someone else more versed will chime in on that.

And nothing if this has any bearing of you getting what style/look your heart desires in any way. Just good for thought.

 

[faded264]

Oh that’s beautiful! Do you know the measurements of your stones or the overall diameter? My center is a .60ct so I’m trying to compare visually.

Oh man, I wish I could remember! I had it made like 8 years ago by Grace. I just went through my emails to try to find it but couldn’t find my emails with her. I know the center was .68ct, but I think rose cuts may face up a little larger?

Ok I found out the side stones were .64ctw, so about .08ct each. I don’t know their mm measurement though, sorry!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Oh man, I wish I could remember! I had it made like 8 years ago by Grace. I just went through my emails to try to find it but couldn’t find my emails with her. I know the center was .68ct, but I think rose cuts may face up a little larger?

Ok I found out the side stones were .64ctw, so about .08ct each. I don’t know their mm measurement though, sorry!

That’s ok! That should be pretty comparable to what I’m having made so I’m excited because yours is lovely!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

I like the looks of it!

I’m no expert - with that being said - was always under the impression in antique settings like this, the prongs that you had removed had actually snapped/been worn away. With a few remaining in other areas. The ones that had remaining bits at that point looked more like tab prongs and the stones weren’t chipped but plenty of the stones with missing prongs were.
It looks like DKJ went ahead and enlarged the ‘v’ prongs, my question would be was that scaled up enough for the stones be secure in the long run. Again - the ones I’ve seen/had once those prongs wore away the remaining ‘v’ left the stone a bit wobbly.
I’m not saying DKJ would intentionally produce something unsecure.
Again - I have no proof that cluster rings like this weren’t ever intentionally made this way - just my impression of what I’ve seen.
Maybe someone else more versed will chime in on that.

And nothing if this has any bearing of you getting what style/look your heart desires in any way. Just good for thought.

I completely agree with every point you’ve made, thank you so much for weighing in! I asked him to edit the CADs if he thought the stones would be secure because like you, I was concerned that they wouldn’t be. I did notice the other prongs between the stones were “beefed up” so to speak so I think that will compensate for the lack of outer prongs. He didn’t hesitate to edit the design or speak to anything regarding the stones not being properly secured so I’m confident that they’ll be ok. If anyone sees anything that raises concern, please speak up because this is my very first custom project.

If it’s at all helpful, this is the link I sent him from JBG as an example. I *think* the design is intentional and the prongs haven’t been worn down or snapped off, simply because of the consistency of the design all around the edges. What are your thoughts?

4.65ctw "Sunrise" Orange-Pink Padparadscha Sapphire & Diamond Cluster Ring, No-Heat

One of the prettiest cluster rings in our current collection! Of course, this luscious orangey-pink "Sunrise" padparadscha no-heat sapphire is the clear star of the show, with its deeply saturated pink-salmon tones, set amidst a surround of chunky old mine cut diamonds in warm rose gold. Charm...

www.jewelsbygrace.com

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

CAD is approved, DK has my diamond in hand as of Thursday, and now the painful waiting process begins.

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

It’s finished!

 

[YadaYadaYada]

Very pretty, love the design and especially those perfect prongs!

 

[ItsMainelyYou]

It turned out beautifully! I love it, I love it. Can't wait to see it on the hand.

 

[maryjane04]

Its beautiful!!! Love this design

 

[tyty333]

Gorgeous! Looks like they got it how you wanted it...what do you think @michellelynn9175 ?

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Gorgeous! Looks like they got it how you wanted it...what do you think @michellelynn9175 ?

I love it! I’d have to have it in hand before I can say for sure but I think it’s exactly what I had my heart set on!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Very pretty, love the design and especially those perfect prongs!

DK executes some amazing prong work!

 

[emmy12]

Wowwwww! Stunning! It looks PERFECT and 0% like a daisy! Can't wait to see hand shots. Beautiful!

ETA: the prongs are beautiful, the side stones are a lovely proportion, and I ESPECIALLY love the side profile view. The basket looks so delicate. I'm in love. Now I think I need one of these in the future!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Wowwwww! Stunning! It looks PERFECT and 0% like a daisy! Can't wait to see hand shots. Beautiful!

ETA: the prongs are beautiful, the side stones are a lovely proportion, and I ESPECIALLY love the side profile view. The basket looks so delicate. I'm in love. Now I think I need one of these in the future!

I really think taking those outer prongs off made all the difference. I was really particular about the proportions but I think it’s just what I wanted. I definitely preferred more cluster and less of a halo look. I’m hoping the center isn’t too big!

And do it! DK is so reasonable and easy to work with. I never thought I’d have a piece of his, but I’m grateful I finally will. It’s been about 6 years since I first discovered him and my taste has changed over and over. Hoping this will be an heirloom piece!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Hand shots!

 

[FutureChocolateMLK]

Hey everyone! For those following my thread, I’ve listed my ring over on LT. It’s been reduced too if anyone is interested!