risingsun
Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2006
- Messages
- 5,549
I asked this question earlier in the thread. How many responding to this post are or have been parents of a teenager. As a former parent of a teenage girl I can tell you that it was the biggest shock of my life. My loving little daughter became someone I didn't know. I loved her, but I didn't like her very much, at times. It was a miracle we made it through ages 15-20! At some point, in her twenties, the values she learned throughout her life really hit home for her. My daughter was back--with many lessons learned. I was a single parent through much of my daughter's life. I doubted myself. I received positive feedback about my parenting from family and friends. I asked how could my daughter be so diffcult? Someone responded that she was independent, like her mother, and someday it would serve her well. In the long run, it has served her well. We love each other and are proud of each others' accomplishments. It has been a long, wild and unpredictable ride.Date: 2/25/2009 10:26:38 PM
Author: vespergirl
Hey everyone, I just wanted to respond to my own post, which was a specific reply to zhuzhu's and beebrisk's, which was discussing whether any of us on here were coming from a parent's position. I'm not trying to say that the opinions of teachers or non-parents don't count, but I do believe that there is a profound understanding of parenting that only comes with being a parent. I just feel that until you are a parent, you cannot really understand how the dynamic between you & your own child will work, and just how deep and sacred the relationship can be - there really is no comparison to any other type of relationship I've experienced. And, I will add that my son is still a little guy, but just a few years of parenting have had such a profound affect on my relationship with him, myself and the rest of the world. So, no disrespect meant to the opinions of others, but I still do feel that until your 'in the club' and standing in a parent's shoes, it's hard to judge what you would do in those particular circumstances.Date: 2/25/2009 7:19:13 PM
Author: vespergirl
How interesting that so many people without children have such strong convictions about parenting. As a parent, I find it ridiculous that people without children think that they can offer valuable parenting advice. It's as silly as Catholic priests providing marriage counseling.Date: 2/25/2009 6:18:54 PM
Author: beebrisk
Date: 2/25/2009 2:34:05 PM
Author: zhuzhu
beebrisk,
Do you mind me asking if you have had or have teenage children of your own? I am just curious as to if your strong belief is theoretical in nature, or if you had a success story of your own based on your preferred parenting style.
Funny really, that in light of the many 'strong beliefs' being thrown around this thread you ask only me for justification?
I find your question quite interesting really, but it's one that brings up a whole host of issues, none of which I'll go into here as it would lead us off the original topic.
Suffice to say, my opinion has been formed and forged in reality--not psycho-babble.
Nuff said.
And as for people who work with children, I think they do a great service to society, but it's still a different ballgame than parenting. For example, one of my best friends, who is a pre-K teacher, has frequently been critical of the parenting skills of other people we know in our community. She has always felt that she understands what it means to raise young children because of her job, and has sometimes spoken in a condescending manner to parents that she feels are subpar. Recently, however, she had her first child. She has confided to me how completely overwhelmed and stunned she is by motherhood. She would always say that she takes care of young kids all day, so she knows it isn't that hard, but she just told me that now that she understands the 24/7 demands of parenting, she has a completely different attitude towards those parents that she judged before.
So basically, I feel that unless you are a parent, your opinions on parenting don't hold as much water.
I also have a question for Beebrisk regarding her assertion that her opinions are based in reailty - are you suggesting that my experience or zhuzhu's are not based in reality? How could they not be if they are indeed true and real? Could you share with us what your 'reality ' is so that we can understand where you are coming from? I am asking because I didn't understand your answer to her question - I see a lot of defensive posturing, and insult-hurling (why is an intelligently-phrased question accused of being 'psycho-babble'? Did you not understand the question?), but no explanations as to what your reality is and why you feel the way you do. You still haven't let us know if you're speaking from the position of a teenager, parent, minister, etc., because any thinking person would realize that the 'realities' of those people would all be very different. I am interested in hearing more about your perspective so that I can understand where you're coming from.