1.5 d vs2 or 1.52 f vs2...idealscope included

[Mlh]

1.5 D vs2: hca 1.5.


1.52 f vs2 hca 1.3

 

[Kaycee2018]

Between the two, I’m liking the 1.52 F VS2 based on the info provided. Links to the videos would help though.

 

[Mlh]

Between the two, I’m liking the 1.52 F VS2 based on the info provided. Links to the videos would help though.

Thanks @Kaycee2018 ! You have such great taste! I love your rings!!

 

[Mlh]

@Karl_K , @Garry H (Cut Nut) would love your thoughts if you get a chance.

 

[lovedogs]

@Karl_K , @Garry H (Cut Nut) would love your thoughts if you get a chance.

They can't comment on another vendor's product due to the rules of the forum.

Edit. I guess you cropped out the vendor info, but pretty much everyone will know who the vendor is bc of the website style. So in this case I'm actually not sure if people in the trade are allowed to comment or not (they can comment on pics as long as they aren't directly linked to a specific vendor)

 

[Mlh]

They can't comment on another vendor's product due to the rules of the forum.

Edit. I guess you cropped out the vendor info, but pretty much everyone will know who the vendor is bc of the website style. So in this case I'm actually not sure if people in the trade are allowed to comment or not (they can comment on pics as long as they aren't directly linked to a specific vendor)

Oh wow. Even just between the two? Thanks @lovedogs .... I didn't realize. Apologies.

 

[tyty333]

Of course, the 34.5/40.8 combo is the preferred combo (and it has a slightly better idealscope). I would probably go with the F/VS2. The D isnt
bad either though IMO.

 

[Mlh]

Of course, the 34.5/40.8 combo is the preferred combo (and it has a slightly better idealscope). I would probably go with the F/VS2. The D isnt
bad either though IMO.

Thank you @tyty333 ! Girdle is a bit thicker at 4. I guess that shouldn't matter too much

 

[mwilliamanderson]

If I hadnt seen the numbers on these and only looked at the ideal scope imagesI would have said pass. How am I reading these wrong. I thought the red should have the same saturation across the diamond and that light pink areas indicate leakage. Can someone school me? I really want to learn. Would these be considered Very Good but Not Excellent as in this photo?

 

[lovedogs]

If I hadnt seen the numbers on these and only looked at the ideal scope imagesI would have said pass. How am I reading these wrong. I thought the red should have the same saturation across the diamond and that light pink areas indicate leakage. Can someone school me? I really want to learn. Would these be considered Very Good but Not Excellent as in this photo?

Compare the red to the color of the very middle. Anything lighter than that = leakage. But if the image is overly back lit, the middle will look pinkish vs red. So in these examples, I see some leakage in the D but not in the F

 

[mwilliamanderson]

Compare the red to the color of the very middle. Anything lighter than that = leakage. But if the image is overly back lit, the middle will look pinkish vs red. So in these examples, I see some leakage in the D but not in the F

That helps, thanks @lovedogs!

 

[Mlh]

Compare the red to the color of the very middle. Anything lighter than that = leakage. But if the image is overly back lit, the middle will look pinkish vs red. So in these examples, I see some leakage in the D but not in the F

@lovedogs , the f looks good to you then?

 

[lovedogs]

@lovedogs , the f looks good to you then?

Yeah I like it!

 

[stonehunter20]

i would go for f, because: 1. i personally don't think it's worth getting a d color; 2. there seems to be some light leakage under the table in d diamond. just my two cents.

 

[Mlh]

i would go for f, because: 1. i personally don't think it's worth getting a d color; 2. there seems to be some light leakage under the table in d diamond. just my two cents.

I agree. I was really looking for a G

 

[Snowdrop13]

There are surely plenty of G VS2 in this size range, please don’t restrict yourself to the choice between a D and an F if you really want a G! Probably will cost less too.

 

[Mlh]

Thanks everyone. I am going to pass on both. I appreciate everyone who weighed in

 

[tyty333]

If I hadnt seen the numbers on these and only looked at the ideal scope imagesI would have said pass. How am I reading these wrong. I thought the red should have the same saturation across the diamond and that light pink areas indicate leakage. Can someone school me? I really want to learn. Would these be considered Very Good but Not Excellent as in this photo?

I remember Garry H telling us that we are usually overly critical when looking at an idealscope.

@Mlh Can you tell us why you are passing on these?

 

[Mlh]

Hi @tyty333 , I guess the short answer is gut feeling. I thought they were strong contenders. Now I am questioning it. I am in no rush. This is for an upgrade. I have a beautiful diamond currently. Thanks for taking an interest!