Whiteflash ACA selection help

[Justin_P]

I understood it as both the H and F were eye clean from the top.

 

[blueMA]

How about this one? G VS2, although inclusion smack under the table, prob eye-clean.
http://www.agslab.com/pdf_sync_reports/104095238018-PGRH.PDF

 

[Justin_P]

Agree with @Lorelei.
When making any tough decision, you need to first define what is the most significant and determining factor to YOU. I think you have some solid choices, and I could support arguments for each diamond. For me, it breaks down as this:

- F for the color
- I for the size
- H for the cut & clarity

Quick question. For the H, you mention cut. What do you mean? Do you see something in the angles or proportions that leads you to believe it would be better?

I read about smaller tables and steeper crowns, but when looking between the small difference between the F and H, would I/anyone notice? I like the idea of more fire, but looking at the videos I don't see a real difference.

 

[blueMA]

No, I think he just mentioned the cut to add on the superior clarity. No real difference in the performance, but I do prefer stones less than 61.8 in depth. I like the G stone - have them examine it next to the H.

 

[Justin_P]

Done. Went with the F, the H was actually sold right before I called them.

Thanks everyone!!

 

[TweetyBird23]

She’s going to be thrilled! Congrats!

 

[blueMA]

Yeah~

 

[Lorelei]

It's going to be gorgeous AND an F too, congratulations or congrates as our Karl says!

 

[ac117]

Done. Went with the F, the H was actually sold right before I called them.

Thanks everyone!!

Fantastic!!! She's going to love it!!

 

[sledge]

Quick question. For the H, you mention cut. What do you mean? Do you see something in the angles or proportions that leads you to believe it would be better?

I read about smaller tables and steeper crowns, but when looking between the small difference between the F and H, would I/anyone notice? I like the idea of more fire, but looking at the videos I don't see a real difference.

My opinion of the cut was subjective and based on the videos. While I thought all the diamonds were gorgeous, I felt the H had a little extra oomph to it. You really had 3 excellent choices and in those moments I think you take that one that speaks to you. For me, the H spoke and I was listening.

I'm sorry you missed the H, but the F is a fantastic choice and I do love the color! Your girl will be extremely pleased and be in sparkle heaven! Congrats!!