Which Stone Has Better Ratios??

[lafive0]

Can I please get some feedback on the following two stones, thanks!

Princess Cut (both)

- EGL USA
- 1.00 Carat Russian Cut
- G VS2
- 5.45x5.41x4.01mm
- 64% Table x 74.1% Depth
- Polish: Good
- Symmetry: Good
- Culet: None
- Girdle: Very Thin - Slightly Thick
- Fluorescence: None

Price: $4800

- AGS
- 1.03 Carat Indian Cut
- H SI1
- 5.56x5.55x4.06
- 65% Table 73.2% Depth
- Polish: Ideal
- Symmetry: Ideal
- Culet: None
- Girdle: Thin-Medium
- Fluorescence: None
(This stone is much shallower)

Price: $4970

 

[bcavitt]

Can I please get some feedback on the following two stones, thanks!

Princess Cut (both)

- EGL USA
- 1.00 Carat Russian Cut
- G VS2
- 5.45x5.41x4.01mm
- 64% Table x 74.1% Depth
- Polish: Good
- Symmetry: Good
- Culet: None
- Girdle: Very Thin - Slightly Thick
- Fluorescence: None

Price: $4800

- AGS
- 1.03 Carat Indian Cut
- H SI1
- 5.56x5.55x4.06
- 65% Table 73.2% Depth
- Polish: Ideal
- Symmetry: Ideal
- Culet: None
- Girdle: Thin-Medium
- Fluorescence: None
(This stone is much shallower)

Price: $4970

The AGS stone looks better all around first of all because you can believe the color and clarity grading, the polish & symmetry is better, and the stone is not all that much shallower (if you can see 0.05 mm of difference, I'll eat my hat). If you can get them, get an ASET to check the cut.