which one if any is a better diamond? or should I keep looking?

[akulashark]

Please help me decide between these two diamonds. The price of the two is same a little over my $10K budget. I am looking for around a 2 Ct diamond that sparkles and looks the bigger for diamond that you can get for around $10-11K. is any of the two a good pick? or should I continue the search. Thanks

First one is 2 Ct J SI1 8.15 x 8.21x 4.87 mm GIA 3x James and Allen with an HCA of 1.3

Table 60
depth 59.5
crown angle 33.0
Pavillion angle 40.8
med to slightly thick faceted
fluorescence None




Second one is 2.26 Ct J SI1 8.3-8.37 x 5.23 mm GIA 3x


HCA 2 to 2.2
Table 56
depth 62.8
crown angle 36.5
pavilion angle 40.6
flouresence Faint
med to slightly thick faceted

 

[tyty333]

These arent numbers we normally suggest.

Can you provide links to the stones?

Edit...

No on the first one...its got issues.

Do you have a link to the second one? Can you get an idealscope image for it?

 

[akulashark]

These arent numbers we normally suggest.

Can you provide links to the stones?

Edit...

No on the first one...its got issues.

Do you have a link to the second one? Can you get an idealscope image for it?

Thanks for the reply. No don't have ideal scope image for it.
here is the link for the second. its HCA and GIA report are in the Original post. Thanks again!

2.26 Carat Round Diamond

Shop for diamonds with confidence using our Transparent Diamond Pricing tool. Discover high-quality engagement rings, wedding rings, & fine jewelry.

www.ritani.com

 

[OoohShiny]

I think that both would work (in terms of the angles) but both are very different 'flavours' - the first being a 60/60 (favouring white light return over coloured fire) and the second being a small table / high crown (vice versa).