Which eternity band(s) would you choose?

[mimi72]

This is my Leon Mege e-ring:
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/my-leon-upgrade-emerald-cut-with-french-cut-sides.173652/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/my-leon-upgrade-emerald-cut-with-french-cut-sides.173652/[/URL]

I love it dearly, but want something a little less flashy for certain days at work.

I set out to buy a plain platinum band, but was seduced by diamond eternity bands. I've wanted one for about 20 years anyway.

Both options are in platinum, appear low set, closed basket shared prong settings, full diamond eternity, size 5.75, appear well made with comfortable prongs.

Option 1: one band, 25 point stones, 4.25 ctw, F-G, VS, very good cut quality, unbranded. Very pretty and love the larger size.

Option 2: Two bands that can be stacked, both with 10 point stones, 2 ctw per band, branded high quality (eg Tiffany, Cartierr, HW), D-E, VVS-VS. This option is about $3k more than option 1. Advantages are brand/known maker and the flexibility to wear only one at a time for a low key look.

Both are from non-local but reputable vendors who offer an inspection period.

Votes??

 

[Acinom]

Could you post pics Mimi?

 

[mimi72]

I do not have photos, sorry. I guess I just wanted opinions on whether, given the above factors/differences, people would recommend one larger band or two smaller bands, with approx equal ctw. I suppose it's largely a personal preference issue.

 

[junebug17]

I think I would prefer a single band.

 

[Acinom]

For me it depends on the look on your finger... Both options can be stunning.
Personally I love stacking so the option of two bands appeal to me. Personally I would opt for two Erika Winters bands because of the modern classic look and unique feel.

I love love love your Leon ring by the way I have a version with OEC and french cuts, made by VC.

 

[tyty333]

I think it depends if you plan on continuing to collect stacking bands. If you like the idea of getting more bands and mixing/matching
then I would go with the two bands. If that idea doesnt really appeal to you then I would stick with the single, bigger eternity band.

 

[Acinom]

+1 to my own post: would you consider a wider french cut band?

 

[mimi72]

I prefer simplicity and don't think I'm interested in mix/matching other bands. It sounds like a more modern look though...at 43 I'm getting out of touch.

Acinom, thanks for the compliment on my ring. VC's work is amazing too. I have a dearly prized Cuprian Mozambique tourmaline which I will have reset by him *someday*.

 

[mimi72]

Acinom, I think I'll choose between these options. The French cut bands I've seen on PS are stunning, but not now. I don't intend to wear this band with my Leon, so the matching isn't a concern.

 

[FightGravity]

It sounds like you tried them on? Which option did you like better on your hand?

I love a big eternity on its own, and/or mismatched stacked bands (e.g. A big eternity plus a micropave, or any two of the gorgeous Erika winters bands) over 2 matched 10pt bands. But it really comes down to what you like best!

 

[mimi72]

I have not tried them on. The sellers are not local but there is an inspection period in case I want to return. I'm leaning toward the single larger eternity band based on comments and the fact that when I have looked at bands on the past, I've wanted bigger stones.

 

[FightGravity]

Go try some in the same sizes at a local jeweler! I bet it will make the decision much easier.

 

[AprilBaby]

If wearing alone get the .25 stones. If you want simple days and mix and match days get the .10's. I have .10 and I love it. I prefer the simple look but I wear it with my ering and without. If I were wearing primarily without I would probably upgrade.

 

[LLJsmom]

Option 2. IMO, Your ring doesn't really need a band at all. So if you wear one, it's clearly extraneous (not in a bad way), and you are wearing it just to stack. The only way it would not seem separate is if you made a matching one. Just my 2c.

 

[Rockinruby]

Just going by your comments...it sounds like one larger ring is better for your lifestyle and preferences. Is it an option to try on something similar or get these in so you can see what you prefer in person?

 

[tyty333]

Can you order both and send back the one you don't want?

Sounds like the single big one may be more up your alley.

 

[mimi72]

LLJsmom - I don't intend to wear the band with my LM ring. Agree it's extraneous. This band is to have something less flashy at work or other times when I don't want to scream "huge diamond!".

I can't get both at the same time, but I might try the larger band and see how I like it. It is not huge compared with some of the eternity bands on PS, but 25 pointers will still be pretty eye catching. I may be defeating my original purpose of getting something low key, but "go big or go home."

 

[LLJsmom]

LLJsmom - I don't intend to wear the band with my LM ring. Agree it's extraneous. This band is to have something less flashy at work or other times when I don't want to scream "huge diamond!".

I can't get both at the same time, but I might try the larger band and see how I like it. It is not huge compared with some of the eternity bands on PS, but 25 pointers will still be pretty eye catching. I may be defeating my original purpose of getting something low key, but "go big or go home."

Sorry mimi, I wasn't paying attention. You wanted a non-ering day band. I see.
I think 25 pointers would make a very blingy and beautiful eternity. Can't wait to see it!

 

[carabella]

I agree - a single, substantial band seems like the way to go. It will be beautiful!