Which diamond would you pick?

[Sanibel13]

Hello e everybody,
which of this two diamonds would YOU pick?

Both are G color, VVS2 clarity, triple X GIA Diamonds.

Nr.1.

Carat 0.8
Depth 60.8
Table 58
Crown Angle 34.0
Pavillon Angle 40.8
Inclusion Needle/Pinpoint
HCA 1.1


Nr. 2.

Carat 0.81
Depth 60.4
Table 57
Crown Angle 34.5
Pavillon Angle 40.8
Inclusion Feather
HCA 1.2

Thank you very much for your help !!!!

 

[ecf8503]

More "desirable inclusions" on the first one.

Can you get idealscope images? The HCA is a weedout tool; the next step is to get an idealscope image.

 

[Sanibel13]

No.. I can't get an Idealoscope picture. I just have the numbers.
Do you think the feather is a problem i a VVS2 stone?
Thank you for your answer!

 

[Gypsy]

I would drop the VVS and see if you can eek out a little size. Vs2 is fine.
I wouldn't pay for VVS in a round.

 

[Sanibel13]

If you had to choose one of this two - which one would you choose and why? Can I see any difference between a diamond with a 57% Table and one with a 58% Table? Is a Feather something to worry about in a VVS2 Diamond?

Thank you really much for helping me !!!

 

[LaraOnline]

I actually quite like a large-ish table, but tbh I don't have a strong opinion between the two table wise.
If you have an opportunity to avoid a feather, and all other aspects of the stones are equal (have you seen them both in person?) I probably would avoid a feather. Although at the clarity you're looking at, it's not a big feather. we're getting nit picky here.

If I had the opportunity, I would examine both of them in person and make the choice from there.
Is there a difference in the lower pavilion facet percentages?
Does either of them have fluoro?

 

[Gypsy]

No there is no need to avoid a VVS feather. No need to avoid anything in VVS, or even VS1.

It's not nitpicking, it's just sense.

If it were my ring I'd drop to H-I eyeclean SI1 and get a full carat.

 

[Sanibel13]

Okay, thank you..
When I don't have to worry about the feather, maybe the smaller table would be better?
I have a 3.75 finger- so I think, 0.8 carat will be a nice size for me.. ?