Which 2.5ct is a better pick? Help

[diamondnewbieny]

Hello all! My jeweler showed me 2 options of 2.5ct diamond that both will cost me $21k. Details on both diamond below. Please help me decided which one is a better buy. Also please don’t mind the pictures because that’s what my jeweler sent me.

With the information my jeweler gave me I think the 2.55ct is a better buy, but I just want to confirm. Because there are people on here have much better knowledge than me.

Thanks in advance.

2.55ct I color VS1 Strong blue fluorescence GIA
Jeweler confirmed with the diamond source no brown milky and green.
Table 57 depth 62 crown 34.5 pavilion 40.8
HCA 1.5 with 3 excellent and 1 very good

2.56ct I color VS1 Strong blue fluorescence GIA
Not much info on this one
Table 57 depth 62.4 crown 36 pavilion 40.6
HCA 1.9 with 3 very good and 1 excellent

 

[flyingpig]

I agree with you. The 2.55 is good. It is not the best, but very attractively priced.
The IS and ASET images are not well taken. The diamond is tilted and backlight is too strong. Any light leakage you see in these photos are a bit exaggerated.