Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

What would you rather...?

What would you rather

  • A 2ct Diamond?

    Votes: 46 67.6%

  • Or a 1ct Unheated Ruby?

    Votes: 22 32.4%
  • Total voters
    68
  • Poll closed .
The sun is shining

The sun is shining

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Jan 26, 2008
Messages
178
A quick poll; if you had the choice between a 1ct unheated ruby or a 2ct diamond, assuming you had neither, what would you choose?

Part of me questions if one is going to rise significantly higher in price over time to prevent it from being accessible monetarily, although one could argue the unheated ruby by it's very nature is likely to become inaccessible due to availability.

I am on the fence with this one.

Over to you.
 
My vote shouldn't count.. I picked the diamond and I know "ZERO" about rubies including unheated but it sounds like it might be rare....and fabulous!
 
Although red is my favorite color.....Diamonds are this girls best friend 2 carats :appl: :appl: :appl:
 
Mayk|1383870636|3552418 said:
My vote shouldn't count.. I picked the diamond and I know "ZERO" about rubies including unheated but it sounds like it might be rare....and fabulous!
Click to expand...

That's precisely why your vote does count! Very few people have knowledge when it comes to the real world, unless you meet a fellow CS nut that is :wink2:
 
Like Mayk, I know nothing about rubies. As such, I went with the diamond. Is a 2 ct diamond comparable to a 1 ct unheated ruby? I have no idea. All I know is that diamonds are beautiful, easily recognizable, and very valuable (for reasons other than rarity). Plus, the diamond is twice as big as the ruby. What are the stats? Are we assuming that they are both perfect stones?
 
I'm a glitter girl not a color girl for a main stone. Diamond for me!
 
smilligan said:
Like Mayk, I know nothing about rubies. As such, I went with the diamond. Is a 2 ct diamond comparable to a 1 ct unheated ruby? I have no idea. All I know is that diamonds are beautiful, easily recognizable, and very valuable (for reasons other than rarity). Plus, the diamond is twice as big as the ruby. What are the stats? Are we assuming that they are both perfect stones?
Click to expand...

Lets assume the diamond is a J, SI1 ideal cut; the ruby is of Sri Lankan (Ceylon) origin.
 
Much as I love rubies, if I had neither, then it has got to be a diamond!

DK :))
 
I love diamonds. And am not a colored stone girl. Not because I don't like color I do. But because I truly ONLY care about color and sparkle. Not the unheated/ treatment. Not the natural aspect of it. I don't care I'd its mined or cultured

So if I wanted a ruby. I'd get a ruby. But not an expensive one.
 
I just love diamonds. Ruby is my birthstone though. I always think I should get one. I like sapphires more than rubies.
 
twelve thousand dollar diamonds are $144,000. a dozen. A dozen 1 ct unheated rubies of similar value might take you a lifetime to find.
i would take the ruby while I could.
 
VapidLapid|1383876105|3552492 said:
twelve thousand dollar diamonds are $144,000. a dozen. A dozen 1 ct unheated rubies of similar value might take you a lifetime to find.
Click to expand...

This.
 
So long as it was the right color and clarity ruby, I would pick the ruby because the color pops.
 
Hands down the ruby!!! You could get the diamond any day of the week. I know a woman with a 3 ct very high quality ruby. It's jaw dropping...
 
I only voted for the 2 ct diamond because a 1 ct ruby is too small for me for a ring stone. Rubies are more dense than diamonds, and a well cut 1 ct ruby will have a smaller face up size than a 1 ct diamond. Just a personal preference.

If you had asked me to chose between a 2 ct diamond a burmese, unheated top red ruby with the same face up dimensions, I would vote for the ruby.
 
That's a hard one.

Depends on how you set that Ruby. But probably the ruby. In a really cool deco setting with a halo.

But it also depends on the ruby itself. Unheated isn't enough. The color would have to be just the color I wanted. And the cutting would need to have no windowing or other large flaws.

IF it was a color I loved and the cut was nice... definitely the ruby.
 
First off, ditto to VapidLapid - the rarity value tends to be a big draw for me. These days more in terms of vintage/craftsmanship - it would take a crowbar to pry my rare acquisitions out of my hands (like, to the point where I would not trade my 3 carat french cut eternity for a six carat modern RB band) - but the principle still applies.

Gypsy said:
That's a hard one.

Depends on how you set that Ruby. But probably the ruby. In a really cool deco setting with a halo.
Click to expand...

Also, this. I am normally the Empress of Size Queens, but I just got a 1 carat ish ruby and it doesn't feel small at *all,* thanks to the setting. Jewelry is almost always as much about the metal as the rock, in my opinion ... Odd, how often that seems to be the exception, opinion-wise! Which is not meant as a slight to anyone ... I genuinely wonder if I'm a weirdo for caring so much about settings. Maybe it's coming from the same part of my brain that prioritizes rarity value ....

P.S. - For me, the choice of the ruby would be influenced by the fact that most rubies have a beautiful fluorescence, one of my very favorite qualities. Make it a toss-up between a beautifully cut old ruby and a VSBF OEC with eye-visible fluor, and I'd have rather a harder time of it ....
 
Hah, wrong question to ask me. :bigsmile: Untreated, pure red 1 ct ruby with unreal saturation, glow and fluorecence. Origin wouldn't matter if the colour is right. A stone like that would be incredibly difficult to replace. You can find a 2 ct diamond within the week whilst it might take a year to find the right ruby. When the colour is fine, that's all people notice. It makes the stone stand out so I'm okay with a smaller ruby.
 
If a ruby expert is choosing the ruby for me, I would go for the ruby. I saw some beautiful ones in real life and they are amazing. And I know nothing about colored stones. Also, the ruby color really works with my skin tone, and it's my daughter's birthstone. I really want to buy a high quality one to give to her someday, but I just don't know where to start. Ruby definitely.
 
Gypsy|1383879489|3552540 said:
That's a hard one.

Depends on how you set that Ruby. But probably the ruby. In a really cool deco setting with a halo.

But it also depends on the ruby itself. Unheated isn't enough. The color would have to be just the color I wanted. And the cutting would need to have no windowing or other large flaws.

IF it was a color I loved and the cut was nice... definitely the ruby.
Click to expand...

Yes and yes.

Circe said:
I am normally the Empress of Size Queens, but I just got a 1 carat ish ruby and it doesn't feel small at *all,* thanks to the setting. Jewelry is almost always as much about the metal as the rock, in my opinion ... Odd, how often that seems to be the exception, opinion-wise! Which is not meant as a slight to anyone ... I genuinely wonder if I'm a weirdo for caring so much about settings. Maybe it's coming from the same part of my brain that prioritizes rarity value ....

P.S. - For me, the choice of the ruby would be influenced by the fact that most rubies have a beautiful fluorescence, one of my very favorite qualities. Make it a toss-up between a beautifully cut old ruby and a VSBF OEC with eye-visible fluor, and I'd have rather a harder time of it ....
Click to expand...

I think size is my concern; I would love a big honking ruby but simply put, my budget doesn't extend that far. Roger Dery has a special one, but extends far beyond what my budget can reach. However the one carat I am looking at is special. Stupidly so.
 
pregcurious|1383878332|3552528 said:
If you had asked me to chose between a 2 ct diamond a burmese, unheated top red ruby with the same face up dimensions, I would vote for the ruby.
Click to expand...

:naughty: Can you spot me a loan? :naughty:
 
Oh. I have just remembered my other issue. I wanted a round ruby. This one is oval. I think if it was round I wouldn't have asked the question.
 
I'm South African so I'd be too scared to wear a 2ct diamond.

I had a 1carat unheated pigeon blood ruby ring from my Gran that was stolen a few years ago.
It's pretty much my holy grail of jewellery so my answer was easy. ::)
 
I voted for the diamond as there is just 'something' about the sparkle. A diamond is a great basic as it fits with every style, color and mood.

That being sad, now that I have several diamonds, my next stone could very well be a ruby :love: the color can be so special!

I your case, I would perhaps grab the ruby as it seems to have your preference?
 
If it was truly THE ruby… I'd go with that. I could find a 2 ct diamond today- right now even. Go click on a couple websites and order me up one real quick (if only I had the cash). THE ruby is a much more difficult find.

However, if it looks like most rubies I see IRL… go with the diamond:)
 
By far the ruby is more rare. The issue I have is the size. It will look small when set compared to the 2ct diamond. So It all depends upon what you plan to do with it. You can bling it up with a halo to get coverage. I have a 1 carat ruby-oval- that I set with side pear diamonds. The ring is very pretty but I wish the sione was bigger as I have big hands.
 
Can you get a bigger ruby?
 
I wonder how differently this poll would tally if it had been placed in Colored Stones with just an announcement and link to it in Rocky Talky.
 
Totally ruby!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top