I am planning to propose to my girlfriend of 3 years and am currently undecided between a ~1 carat Tiffany classic 6-prong setting from T&Co and a ~1 carat Cartier 1895 4-prong setting. Both round brilliant, VS1, F color, platinum. About the same price.
She's pretty classy, likes to dress simple and clean, doesn't wear much jewelry except on special occasions, so I'm not interested in anything too showy like paves or huge/multiple diamonds.
Tiffany or Cartier? Blue box or red box? American or French? If price and the diamond quality are the same, and you have to pick one or the other, which would you pick? And what's the general consensus about 4-prongs or 6-prongs (I know nothing).
Thanks a bunch!
She's pretty classy, likes to dress simple and clean, doesn't wear much jewelry except on special occasions, so I'm not interested in anything too showy like paves or huge/multiple diamonds.
Tiffany or Cartier? Blue box or red box? American or French? If price and the diamond quality are the same, and you have to pick one or the other, which would you pick? And what's the general consensus about 4-prongs or 6-prongs (I know nothing).
Thanks a bunch!