Thoughts on this GIA report?

[diamondnewbie8]

I didn’t ask if this was a “hearts and arrows” or super ideal cut per se, and the diamond looked good to me, but I have some extra spending power that I can use to upgrade to a better cut diamond if possible. How are the proportions? I’m using a halo setting so I’m not too concerned going with bigger carat or better color (the J looked perfectly white face up). All opinions welcome! HCA score of 1.5 for what it’s worth.

 

[jp201845]

I didn’t ask if this was a “hearts and arrows” or super ideal cut per se, and the diamond looked good to me, but I have some extra spending power that I can use to upgrade to a better cut diamond if possible. How are the proportions? I’m using a halo setting so I’m not too concerned going with bigger carat or better color (the J looked perfectly white face up). All opinions welcome! HCA score of 1.5 for what it’s worth.

You need Aset and Idealscope images to confirm light performance and optical symmetry. VVS2 is overkill on clarity I would drop down clarity and increase carat weight.

 

[OoohShiny]

+1 to ASET and IS images being needed for full analysis!

I personally like VVS, though - I have 'mind clean' issues

I think the proportions look decent - HCA score indicates the angles work together, and the 75% LGFs should work to give a good amount of coloured 'fire'