Smaller carat but better cut, clarity, and color?

[whichprincesscut]

A .73ct VVS2 G princess super ideal cut

or

the 1 carat VS2 I color princess ideal cut for $400 more?

*** Both have a table is smaller than the depth (in excellent ranges), slightly thick girdle, no florescence, and LW ratio of 1.02. Site doesn't show pics but does show GIA report.

 

[heididdl]

Bigger stone vvs is over kill I'd rather have a larger stone especially a with this cut

 

[leoshraeder]

THere is no cut graiding in the GIA reports which means the definition of ideal cut is based on the jeweler's perception.

 

[Dreamer_D]

Do you have any images to help verify the "ideal" and "super ideal" labels? The labels the jeweler applies are marketing. It is possible they perform similarly, or the "ideal" could be better than the "super ideal"... can't tell from the GIA report or those categorical labels.