shape
carat
color
clarity

Response to news report Neil was part of as an expert

Karl_K

Super_Ideal_Rock
Staff member
Trade
Joined
Aug 4, 2008
Messages
15,695
http://www.idexonline.com/portal_FullEditorial.asp

"Of all the unlikely sources, two local TV stations in the US may shake people out of their slumber, as Rob Bates reports. They reported on an age-old scam that too many took part in – selling low quality diamonds as high quality goods. The scam is simple: buy low-cost diamonds and have them graded by a lab that has, let’s call it “different” grading standards. What the GIA or AGS may grade as an “I” clarity would get an SI or even a VS2 at such a lab. The difference in price between an I clarity and a VS clarity is hundreds, if not thousands of dollars – depending on the size of the diamond. Combined with how much the diamond’s color gets “upgraded” too, and a consumer will pay much, much more than they should. Now that is personal. "
 
Re: Response to news report Neil was part of by EDAHN GOLAN

I do not understand what you are getting at, Karl. You need more explanation. I am not sure if you realize it but it makes Neil sound like he was involved with wrongdoing. I hope Neil was involved in exposing it, but it needs to be added to your opening post.
 
Re: Response to news report Neil was part of by EDAHN GOLAN

Yikes I thought it was clear...
Neil was involved in helping to make the news report as an expert.
The discussion is here:
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/neil-beaty-on-abc-denver-sd-about-lab-grading-differances.196425/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/neil-beaty-on-abc-denver-sd-about-lab-grading-differances.196425/[/URL]

I am sending admin a message to edit my post and topic to make it more clear.

Sorry for any confusion,
Sorry Neil!
 
Re: Response to news report Neil was part of by EDAHN GOLAN

Karl_K|1387567922|3578246 said:
Yikes I thought it was clear...
Neil was involved in helping to make the news report as an expert.
The discussion is here:
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/neil-beaty-on-abc-denver-sd-about-lab-grading-differances.196425/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/neil-beaty-on-abc-denver-sd-about-lab-grading-differances.196425/[/URL]

I am sending admin a message to edit my post and topic to make it more clear.

Sorry for any confusion,
Sorry Neil!

I understood it. I think it would be clear to anyone that read the first thread, but I can see people getting confused otherwise.
 
Re: Response to news report Neil was part of by EDAHN GOLAN

No worries Karl. Thanks for correcting it. :sun:
 
Re: Response to news report Neil was part of by EDAHN GOLAN

Regarding the editorial:

IS IT JUST ME OR ARE YOU ANGRY TOO?????

OK we have had investigative reporting on
liberal lab grading, clarity enhanced diamonds, fracture filled rubies, "coated CVD" gemstones, under karated gold, gold buying at very low prices..... every year there is a new "consumer alert."
Nothing shocking or new here. I'm angry though. I don't see much progress being made with transparency. The latest "consumer alert" will most likely be swept under the rug. I'll just take a deep breath, relax, and wait for the next one to be aired in December 2014.

IS IT JUST ME????

A Thank You to Neil...we must continue to speak up and represent the best interests of the consumer because
without the support of the consumer, we will all be out of a job.

Happy Holidays everyone!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top