shape
carat
color
clarity

Pls help! Comparing 3 diamonds from JA 1.7-2ct range

sunkissedx3

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
51
I found these 3 diamonds on James Allen. I like square-ish shapes so I like all three shapes. Although the stones range from 1.7-2ct, they are all very close to 7x7mm. The price for them ranges around 14-16k, I forget the exact prices because it doesn't show right now as they have been removed from inventory for the additional ASET images I requested. Please give me your opinions on which stone you think looks best! I would greatly appreciate your help! =D

1) 2.06 H SI1 True Hearts AGS Ideal Princess

link to video: http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut/2.06-carat-h-color-si1-clarity-sku-202842
photo: trueheartsprincess.jpg
AGS report: ags2_8.jpg

Depth %:76.20
Girdle: Thin-Slightly Thick
Table %:58.30
Polish:Ideal
Symmetry:Ideal
Fluorescence:None
L/W/D (mm): 6.98*6.91*5.27

Love this diamond! I like the smaller table, looks similar to Solasfera princess. I believe the Solasfera princess exhibits so much white light brilliance due to its perfect optical symmetry lending to its contrast patterns that you don't normally see in princesses. On GOG I notice most princesses only score in the high white light brilliance category on the BrilliantScope/Gemex, but all the Solasfera princesses score very high. However, I'm concerned that looking straight on, the diamond shows a lot of darkness. Could that be due to too much contrast? Is that a cause of the diamond being cut slightly deep at a depth of 76%? The computer generated ASET image has a lot of blue but I've seen in a picture that the computer generated ASETs usually do: asetprincess.jpg

Another concern is the SI1 clarity grade. I don't mind SI1 clarity as long as it's eye clean and doesn't affect brilliance. My boyfriend is picky about clarity, he doesn't want to see any flaws under 10x magnification. I can see a fuzzy spot in the right corner of the diamond, and in the video you can really see the long feather from the bottom side.

2) 1.90 H IF Radiant

Link to video: http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/radiant-cut/1.90-carat-h-color-if-clarity-sku-207639
photo: jaradiant.jpg
GIA report: giareportjaradiant.jpg

Depth %:68.10
Girdle: Thick-Thick
Table %:64.00
Culet:NN
Polish:Excellent
Symmetry:Excellent
Fluorescence:None
L/W/D (mm): 7.01*6.94*4.73

Internally flawless! Looking at the picture, there seems to be nice brightness and contrast patterns. I can see a bit of blurriness under the table-- less bright or leakage? I don't know about ideal parameters for a radiant and I've requested an ASET which they said they would email me in about 2 days-- will post as soon as i get it.

3) 1.70 G VS Modern Cushion Brilliant

link to video: http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/cushion-cut/1.70-carat-g-color-vs1-clarity-sku-169138
photo: jacushion.jpg
GIA report: giajacushion.jpg

Depth %:65.60
Girdle: Thin-Very Thick
Table %:70.00
Culet:NN
Polish:Very Good
Symmetry:Good
Fluorescence:None
L/W/D (mm): 7.07*6.95*4.56

Looks like it has nice brightness and contrast. Symmetry on this stone is only "good" though compared to Ideal on the princess, and Excellent on the radiant. I've requested an ASET for this stone as well. I see a bit of blurriness/leakage under the table.
 
The princess looks nice - scores a 0 in light performance, which is great.

You'll have to wait on the ASET's for the other 2. Make sure JA pulls all 3 stones so the gemologist can compare them all side by side.
 
Ilove the moden brilliant
 
Well, this is for you? If it is for you, then the princess, I think. I like that it has an AGS0. And it faces up the same as the rest of them.

If it isn't for you, then I'd wait for the ASET. And find out what EXACTLY she was.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top