Pick between these two princess cut diamonds!!!

[whichprincesscut]

I have two princess cuts in mind. Lets say the table, depth, polish, symmetry, girdle, fluorescence, and LW Ratio on both diamonds are the same. According to the following information provided below without pictures, would you pick princess cut diamond number 1 or number 2?

1) Price $3550
Carat= 1.0
Color= I
Clarity= VS2
Cut= Very good

2) Price $3150
Carat= .73
Color= G
Clarity= VVS2
Cut= Ideal

Thank you for reading my post

 

[04diamond<3]

I'd always go for the bigger...but really I'd need a lot more information.

 

[Niel]

Oh this!

Good cut, clarity, amazing setting and amazing price. The discount has that whole ring at 4300. 

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/3380/

I posted this in your other thread. I don't know what her style but the bezel and halo of this setting will add a lot of finger coverage. The stone is quality and that setting is like twice what they are charging for it and its very high quality. let alone the discount on the stone.