Pear diamond help up to $5k budget

[plpinkinsa]

Hello all...I have a couple of stones that I'm looking at. Any opinions/suggestions? All have open culet.

Total Price $3,081.21
http://diamonddealfinder.com/enquiry.php?id_field=5054384
GIA Cert 2175683748
Weight 1.720
Color M
Clarity SI1
Polish Good
Symmetry Good
Depth 56.20%
Table Percent 60.00%
Measurements 10.63 x 6.61 x 3.72
Culet Size Medium
Fluorescence Intensity Faint


Total Price $4,220.96
http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-4878882-1.72-carat-Pear-diamond-K-color-VS1-clarity.aspx
IGI S4A62481
MEASUREMENTS 10.59 x 6.62 x 3.67 mm
WEIGHT 1.72 Carat
CLARITY GRADE VS 1
COLOR GRADE K
FLUORESCENCE None
FINISH
POLISH AND SYMMETRY Very Good
PROPORTIONS Very Good
TOTAL DEPTH 55.4%
TABLE 61.5%
CROWN HEIGHT 11%
PAVILION DEPTH 39%
GIRDLE THICKNESS Sl. Thick To Thick (fac.)
CULET SIZE small
**Pics have been requsted, should get within 24/48 hours

Total Price $5,090
https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/pear-shaped/1.51-carat-k-color-vs1-clarity-sku-2063810
GIA Cert 5171736505
Weight 1.51
Color k
Clarity vs1
Polish vg
Symmetry Good
Depth 59.5%
Table Percent 65.00%
Measurements 10.23*6.48*3.85
Culet Size small
Fluorescence Intensity none

I'm also requesting more info on the following:
total price $2,880
https://www.allurez.com/1.42-carat-pear-diamond/gid/443738
GIA Cert no number listed, cert copy is on website
Carat Weight : 1.42
Color : I
Clarity : I1 (help! looks like cloud?)
Graded By: GIA
Cut Grade : Excellent
Fluorescence : None
Depth : 64.50
Table : 60.00
Polish : Good
Symmetry : Good
Measurements : 9.39 x 6.26 x 4.04 mm

My plan is to set in rose gold. Do you think about the depth? The first 2 are lower than 59%

 

[tyty333]

Is that picture the first stone? It actually looks pretty decent IMO. I think if you are going to buy a stone that is shallow and in a lower
color that you should order it and play with it for a little while to see what you think of it. If you do not like it, or it suffers from
the shallowness, then return it. It's difficult to evaluate pears without videos.

Can you get an aset?

 

[plpinkinsa]

Is that picture the first stone? It actually looks pretty decent IMO. I think if you are going to buy a stone that is shallow and in a lower
color that you should order it and play with it for a little while to see what you think of it. If you do not like it, or it suffers from
the shallowness, then return it. It's difficult to evaluate pears without videos.

Can you get an aset?

tyty333 I'm going with the first option. The stone just spoke to me and I've talked to Martin (USA Certed Diamonds) and he was really helpful and professional. They do have a return policy if I decide it's not what I'm looking for.