Option 1 Vs Option 2 (J vs H)- Help with selection

[shuks]

I currently have 2 options that I am debating on...which one would you choose?
Option 2 is ~$1,000 more expensive
Planning to go with setting in platinum.

Option 1 - SIGNATURE 1.760 J VS2 HEARTS AND ARROWS ROUND
Table % - 55.8
Depth % - 61.5
Crown Angle - 34.5
Pav Angle - 40.7
Measurements - 7.75 X 7.77 X 4.77
Cut - Ideal
Light Performance - Ideal
Fluorescence - Negligible
Polish - Ideal
Symmetry - Ideal

Option 2 - 1.70 - H- VS1 Carat Round (HCA 1.4)
Cut: Excellent
Depth: 62.60
Table: 55.00
Crown Angle - 34.5
Pav Angle - 40.8
Polish: Excellent
Symmetry: Excellent
Girdle: STK
Fluorescence: None
Measurements : 7.63x7.58x4.76

 

[seaurchin]

I'd go with option 2, the higher H color with for a white metal.

 

[lovedogs]

I'd pick option 1 for the precision cut and being slightly less deep and slightly larger (and cheaper). Do you know if your intended (or you, if you're the wearer) is color sensitive?

 

[shuks]

I'd pick option 1 for the precision cut and being slightly less deep and slightly larger (and cheaper). Do you know if your intended (or you, if you're the wearer) is color sensitive?

Thanks for your inputs. Yes, color sensitivity is the issue with Option 1. Want diamond to be not yellow, but just wondering if the the nice cut will make it look better than Option 2 in platinum setting .