Need some advice on two Bluenile Diamonds

[Nancy Q]

Hello,

I am looking for some advice as to which diamond you guys would prefer?

Stats are: 1.51ct, Color: I, Clarity: VVS1, GIA Ideal Cut, Triple Excellent L/W Ratio: 1 Table% 62.1 Depth %: 56% Crown 34.5 Pavilion 40.8 with Medium Blue Florescence.

https://www.bluenile.com/ca/build-y...AMONDS&track=viewDiamondDetails&action=newTab

This one is on hold for me so the link wont bring you to the diamond but if you can put "LD09732029" in the search to look at the diamond it would be greatly appreciated!

Or

Stats are: 1.52ct, Color: I, Clarity: VVS1, GIA Ideal Cut, Triple Excellent L/W Ratio: 1 Table% 61.9 Depth %: 57% Crown 35 Pavilion 40.6 with Medium Blue Florescence.

https://www.bluenile.com/ca/diamond-details/LD08765484

Any advice or opinions would greatly appreciated!

Thank you!

 

[ringo865]

Bumping so you can get some advice now that the workday is ending

 

[ringo865]

OK I was able to look up the one you have on hold. It looks really nice and square is a 1.3 on the HCA tool, which puts it smack dab into a AGS0 territory.

The other stone was not available when I searched for it so I couldn't tell much about it.

If you don't need such high clarity, you could probably get a larger stone for the same price.

Hopefully, others more knowledgeable than I will check in with their thoughts. But Blue Nile does have a good return policy, and this stone does fit in to the desired parameters. I don't believe BN will provide an ideal scope image, but you could ask.

 

[rockysalamander]

#1 by the numbers. Can't see video as BN and my phone don't get along.

Would be worth running search on James Allen down to VS to see all options.

 

[Nancy Q]

For the second option the link wont bring you to the diamond either please put "LD08765484" in the search to look at the diamond it would be greatly appreciated!

 

[Nancy Q]

OK I was able to look up the one you have on hold. It looks really nice and square is a 1.3 on the HCA tool, which puts it smack dab into a AGS0 territory.

The other stone was not available when I searched for it so I couldn't tell much about it.

If you don't need such high clarity, you could probably get a larger stone for the same price.

Hopefully, others more knowledgeable than I will check in with their thoughts. But Blue Nile does have a good return policy, and this stone does fit in to the desired parameters. I don't believe BN will provide an ideal scope image, but you could ask.

Thank you for your advice! I think I would like to stay in VVS1 range for the sake of it being "mind clean". I have had larger diamonds in the past that were VS and I just couldn't seem to get over the small flaws that came with the diamond. That's just me though I know there's nothing wrong with those diamonds.

Can you please see if you can put this LD08765484 into the search in Bluenile to see if you can bring up the diamond? I would really appreciate it!

 

[Nancy Q]

#1 by the numbers. Can't see video as BN and my phone don't get along.

Would be worth running search on James Allen down to VS to see all options.

Thank you!

 

[Nancy Q]

Bumping this to see if I can get a few more responses.