James Allen Vs. Whiteflash Virtual?

[MattEffinCameron]

I have read a lot of posts on here comparing BN and WF and so on, and it seems to me like a majority of people would suggest that due to the comprehensive nature of the information provides about a stone, people here on PS tend to recommend WF. One of the "pros" always mentioned with WF however is that they have the diamonds in-house as opposed to say BN where the diamond is just a listing.

Well I am looking for a cushion cut, 1-1.2ish range, preferably D-F and IF-VS1 and it seems as though WF does not have any such stones "in house". Doesnt look like they have many cushions in house period actually.

James Allen has a nice selection, a GIA report, and I can see the stone via their video thing before purchasing. Is WF still offering something more that should allow me to be more certain of the quality of the stone before purchasing? If so, help me understand what I should be looking for.

 

[JulieN]

What kind of cushion do you want?

Brian Gavin has square H&A.
Good Old Gold has a mix of everything (antique, modern, H&A) and the selection is well curated for cut. Look for ones that has a lifetime guarantee.
James Allen and B2C Jewels: everything, mostly in the modern modified style
Engagement Rings Direct, Diamonds by Lauren, Victor Canera, and some others have a smaller selection, mostly antique style.

 

[MattEffinCameron]

honestly I had looked in stores at cushions a few times and somehow was unaware that there were different kinds of cushions until reading through some threads on PS this afternoon. I know of an "old mine" cut...

I think I want modern to combine the brilliance of a modern stone (like the round that 'everyone' has) with a slightly vintage look that will go well with the ring.