I need a little help with picking a stone.

[sivette1979]

Im trying to decide between an antique pear cut which is smaller
1st option
its a .95ct modified pear (antique pear)
gia cert
Measurements
7.78 x 5.58 x 3.32 mm
Carat Weight
0.95 carat
Color Grade
G
Clarity Grade
VS2
2nd
0.87ct EGL cert pear brilliant (antique pear)
Measurements
7.38x5.81mm
Carat Weight
0.87 carat
Color Grade
D
Clarity Grade
SI1

3rd
1.58 ct gia crt
measurements
10.30 x 6.27 x 4.09
Carat Weight
1.58 carat
Color Grade
M
Clarity Grade
SI2

Im a ring size 3.75. ill have it set in a halo probably i just don't want it to look small.

 

[lovedogs]

We need pics, since these fancy cuts are impossible to judge on numbers alone. Reject the EGL one bc they aren't a trustworthy lab.

 

[doberman]

I don't trust EGL, so that takes one out. It's an antique cut, and I like antique cuts to be a little warmer and size is a factor. I'd have to go with the 3rd option.

 

[tyty333]

Ask for a picture of that M against a white background.

Without pictures we really can comment whether the stones are nice or not.

 

[sivette1979]

1.58 m si2
.95 vs2 g


0.87 D
0.87 d

Another one of the 95



I just found this chunky pear 1.10 vs J unsure of the shadow in the middle

 

[missy]

1.58 m si2
.95 vs2 g


0.87 D
0.87 d

Another one of the 95



I just found this chunky pear 1.10 vs J unsure of the shadow in the middle

OK this opinion is based on solely on the photos you shared above. I LOVE this one.



Chunky monkey facets and so pleasing to the (my) eye. And oooh that culet and the high color is TDF yummy too.

 

[lovedogs]

I love the chunky .95 and the M color from DBL.

Definitely not the 1.10 J. First of all it's much lower color than J, and it's also terribly cut. Make sure you are only looking at reputable vendors, since there are a lot of random eBay sellers that will sell terrible stuff at high prices.

 

[Ss52]

OK this opinion is based on solely on the photos you shared above. I LOVE this one.



Chunky monkey facets and so pleasing to the (my) eye. And oooh that culet and the high color is TDF yummy too.

Just imagine the setting options for the D pear!

 

[elizat]

OK this opinion is based on solely on the photos you shared above. I LOVE this one.



Chunky monkey facets and so pleasing to the (my) eye. And oooh that culet and the high color is TDF yummy too.

I agree. This is my favorite of the bunch. Really lively stone.

 

[Mjay]

The second photo is hands down the best looking. The others don’t even come close imo

 

[sivette1979]

Just imagine the setting options for the D pear!

that's where im stock, I want some finger coverage but I don't want a round oec, and i love old cut pears but they are hard to come by. i was hoping for a 1.5 ct at least. my finger size es 3.75 please ideas for the .95 ct

 

[lovedogs]

that's where im stock, I want some finger coverage but I don't want a round oec, and i love old cut pears but they are hard to come by. i was hoping for a 1.5 ct at least. my finger size es 3.75 please ideas for the .95 ct

You could halo it! Or double halo!!