shape
carat
color
clarity

How to insure if you can't find Comps?

MakingTheGrade

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
13,288
While reading a recent thread on insuring a ring, a lot of the advice seems to be related to finding comparable stones so you know how much to insure for since you'd want enough to buy a similar quality replacement.

But what if it's a jewelry item that is antique or otherwise unique and difficult to find comparisons for since the value in the piece is more related to the age or the bench time or the artistry? Do you go with an appraiser and just insure it at that value since buying a replacement is unlikely to be an easy task? Do you try to find out how much it would cost to remake from scratch?

I'm buying a bracelet preloved from another PSer and don't really know what value to insure it for since it's an unusual design and modified from when she bought it so it's probably unclear to both of us how much this bracelet now "costs" at retail. Do I just insure it based on how much I bought it for? I don't know that I could "replace" it at that cost, but I guess I could put that money towards a different piece of jewelry and call it even.

3F525C8D-858B-4B21-8D90-C6E00FD7B5E6.jpeg
 
I would use a good independent appraiser to check the condition and write an appraisal.
You can also discuss the value question with them.
For a unique item it is very important to get it well documented or a insurance claim could be very painful.
There are a lot of considerations as to which value to insure it for and your appraiser can discuss that with you.

Frankly I would send it to Neil or Dave A.
 
I would use a good independent appraiser to check the condition and write an appraisal.
You can also discuss the value question with them.
For a unique item it is very important to get it well documented or a insurance claim could be very painful.
There are a lot of considerations as to which value to insure it for and your appraiser can discuss that with you.

Frankly I would send it to Neil or Dave A.

I've always wanted to send things to Dave A. Does he do a bulk rate by chance? :P
 
As far as I know yes......
He doesn't have his remote client pricing on his website but here are his other fees to give you a general idea.
https://datlas.com/fees/

I just realized he's very close to me! Oh man, may need to go on a fieldtrip
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top