Help! Not sure if this is the one

[brooklynny]

HCA score of 1.8
Light return excellent
Fire Very good
Scintillation very good
Spread Very good

Problem is that boyfriend does not think it sparkles enough and I was wondering if it has anything to do with the HCA. Please let me know if The Very good ratings should be a major deterrent to purchasing the diamond especially since it is a little lack luster.

 

[MissGotRocks]

The HCA score is good at 1.8. Anything under 2 merits further investigation into a stone.

Have you seen this diamond in person to assess the 'sparkle' or are you simply going by these images? It looks to be a nice stone but in the end, the eyes are the best judge.

If you can tell us what carat weight, color and clarity you are looking for, we can help you find other contenders.

 

[JulieN]

That looks nice.