Help me to choose an oval diamond please

[annastasiia]

Hello everyone!

I'm looking for a 2.5-3ct oval diamond. I found around 20 options with no bow tie. Could anyone help me to choose a diamond with the most sparkle and less light leakage? Thank you so much!

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=1459487438

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=6472879378

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7466163787

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=3455661455

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=5476806885

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=6455704503

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=6461625952

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7452207671

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=6482103704

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7476836800

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=1458612699

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=3455595691

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7466626515

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7466452346

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=6461356049

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7472807091

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=1473024584

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=2477062292

https://www.withclarity.com/products/diamonds?sku=7451661506

 

[tyty333]

Hi @annastasiia

You really need to cut down the number of ovals if you want help. This is too many to evaluate at once.

What you need to look for...
- distinct, well-defined facets flashing on/off (particularly outside of the center area)
-minimal gray mushy areas

These videos (with the stone standing North/South) are the hardest to evaluate. The videos where the stones are at an angle
tell us more.

What are your budget/color requirements? Does it have to be purchased from with clarity?

 

[annastasiia]

Hi @annastasiia

You really need to cut down the number of ovals if you want help. This is too many to evaluate at once.

What you need to look for...
- distinct, well-defined facets flashing on/off (particularly outside of the center area)
-minimal gray mushy areas

These videos (with the stone standing North/South) are the hardest to evaluate. The videos where the stones are at an angle
tell us more.

What are your budget/color requirements? Does it have to be purchased from with clarity?

Thank you so much for your response. I'll try to change it

 

[annastasiia]

I tried to do my own research and I found these 2 diamonds I like the most. Any thoughts?

Diamonds

With Clarity redefines your online experience of shopping for engagement rings, wedding rings & fine jewelry by blending expertise with sustainability. Design your own jewelry with lab-grown or natural diamonds and gemstones.

www.withclarity.com

Diamonds

With Clarity redefines your online experience of shopping for engagement rings, wedding rings & fine jewelry by blending expertise with sustainability. Design your own jewelry with lab-grown or natural diamonds and gemstones.

www.withclarity.com

 

[tyty333]

These are typical 8 main offset faceting patterns. These 2 are not well cut (or lets say, they are typically cut). They will have a lot
mush (gray area that does not return light well) outside the middle area.

I suggest you look for a 6 main or an 8 main where the arrows go through the center of the stone (you can see this by looking at
the clarity diagram, pavilion view). There are 4 main, 6 mains, 8 mains, 8 main offset, and other branded ovals with 10 mains.
Make sure you look at enough to figure out what "look" you like the best. You can find good and bad of each type but in my
research 6 mains and 8 mains tend to have better light return (they are just harder to find :- ( ).

If you give your desired specs and budget I may be able to look around for you later today.

 

[annastasiia]

These are typical 8 main offset faceting patterns. These 2 are not well cut (or lets say, they are typically cut). They will have a lot
mush (gray area that does not return light well) outside the middle area.

I suggest you look for a 6 main or an 8 main where the arrows go through the center of the stone (you can see this by looking at
the clarity diagram, pavilion view). There are 4 main, 6 mains, 8 mains, 8 main offset, and other branded ovals with 10 mains.
Make sure you look at enough to figure out what "look" you like the best. You can find good and bad of each type but in my
research 6 mains and 8 mains tend to have better light return (they are just harder to find :- ( ).

If you give your desired specs and budget I may be able to look around for you later today.

Thank you so much for your response. I'm looking for a diamond specifically from With Clarity. On their website I searched for 2.5-3ct oval around $4000 (and then I would ask for a price adjustment). I was looking for GIA diamond, because somehow I thought that GIA is better than IGI.
It's really hard for me to find that grey much areas in the diamonds you are talking about.
Thank you for your help and have a nice day!
P.S. Sorry for my English, I'm still learning

 

[0515vision]

GIA isn’t necessarily better in the lab grown world. IGI has a solid reputation now, as they were one of the first to recognize labs as diamonds. In fact, there have been instances here on PS when IGI has been stricter on color than GIA.

Opening up your search to include IGI will likely help a lot.

 

[annastasiia]

Sure. I'm looking for any diamond that looks beautiful. Thank you!

 

[annastasiia]

GIA isn’t necessarily better in the lab grown world. IGI has a solid reputation now, as they were one of the first to recognize labs as diamonds. In fact, there have been instances here on PS when IGI has been stricter on color than GIA.

Opening up your search to include IGI will likely help a lot.

GIA isn’t necessarily better in the lab grown world. IGI has a solid reputation now, as they were one of the first to recognize labs as diamonds. In fact, there have been instances here on PS when IGI has been stricter on color than GIA.

Opening up your search to include IGI will likely help a lot.

Also I'm trying to minimize bow tie

 

[tyty333]

Here are the gray mushy areas...the brown area (under the table) will be mushy in most 8 main offset faceting patterns. The green
area will be well-defined distinct facets that return light nicely.


What you want to see as the stone turns is more "nice" facets light up. The videos where the stones stand North/South are very
hard to evaluate. The ones with the stones on their side are easier.


Look for nice facets in the green area marked below.

 

[tyty333]

I literally can not deal with "with clarity"! The images are so small that you have to bring each one up to see if the stones are
any good. Is there is anywhere else you're willing to buy from? Maybe another PSer can help you with withclarity.

 

[annastasiia]

Here are the gray mushy areas...the brown area (under the table) will be mushy in most 8 main offset faceting patterns. The green
area will be well-defined distinct facets that return light nicely.


What you want to see as the stone turns is more "nice" facets light up. The videos where the stones stand North/South are very
hard to evaluate. The ones with the stones on their side are easier.


Look for nice facets in the green area marked below.

Thank you! Now I know a little bit more about what to look for.

 

[annastasiia]

I literally can not deal with "with clarity"! The images are so small that you have to bring each one up to see if the stones are
any good. Is there is anywhere else you're willing to buy from? Maybe another PSer can help you with withclarity.

I don't like ther website either. I'll try to find another retailer

 

[0515vision]

Have you tried Loose Grown Diamond? They tend to have great prices. I thought you needed With Clarity for a particular reason.

 

[annastasiia]

I just liked the setting from WithClarity (I did home preview). Do you know anything about LooseGrownDiamond setting quality?

 

[0515vision]

What sort of setting are you considering? Simple? Complicated? You can always get set somewhere else. I don’t have personal experience with the settings, so I can’t say. In general, it seems that the places with really great craftsmanship will cost a bit more.

 

[annastasiia]

I'm looking for just regular low set with pave. But I already had some problems with The Art of Jewels. They send me a crooked ring and also replaced a center stone without notifying me
I will probably go to my local jeweler for setting.
LooseGrownDiamond doesn't have preview pictures. It makes my searching process complicated. Is there any other retailers you can recommend?

 

[0515vision]

They’re always Ritani, Brian Gavin, Brilliance, Blue Nile, James Allen, Adiamor off the top of my head. Good luck!

 

[annastasiia]

Thank you!

 

[annastasiia]

Any thoughts on this diamond?

You are being redirected...

 

[tyty333]

Any thoughts on this diamond?

You are being redirected...

Pretty sure this has blue nuance.

 

[0-0-0]

Any thoughts on this diamond?

You are being redirected...

Loupe360

loupe360.com

I’m not really a fan of ovals but I really like the powdery blue color on this one. Odd that the blue nuance is not noted on the report.

 

[annastasiia]

Pretty sure this has blue nuance.

Is the brilliance OK?

 

[annastasiia]

Loupe360

loupe360.com

I’m not really a fan of ovals but I really like the powdery blue color on this one. Odd that the blue nuance is not noted on the report.

Is blue nuance bad for the diamond?

 

[0-0-0]

It just gives it a blue tint instead of the more typical yellow/brown. Some like it some don’t. If it’s next to diamonds without blue nuance the blue tint stands out more.

 

[annastasiia]

There are so many things I have to know. It feels like by the time I find my diamond I become a diamond expert

 

[annastasiia]

It just gives it a blue tint instead of the more typical yellow/brown. Some like it some don’t. If it’s next to diamonds without blue nuance the blue tint stands out more.

Thank you!

 

[annastasiia]

It just gives it a blue tint instead of the more typical yellow/brown. Some like it some don’t. If it’s next to diamonds without blue nuance the blue tint stands out more.

I tried to do my research on a diamond, and it seams like that "blue nuance" diamond is the best choice for the price. I like the brilliance and characteristics. Do you like this diamond? Is blue nuance going to be noticeable once its set?

 

[0-0-0]

In my experience blue nuance is more noticeable in fancy shapes than rounds. I would only buy an oval with blue nuance if I want to see the blue tint. Blue nuance is going to be more noticeable if it’s set in a setting with melee without blue nuance.

 

[annastasiia]

Thank you so much for your advice!