Help me pick ER setting to go with my current band

[Honeybasil]

Trying to finalize how I want to reset my 1 ct diamond, and I would love opinions! (Oops! Ignore my chipping manicure )

 

[distracts]

I like the plain with cushion halo and then the round halo with the larger stones best.

 

[cmd2014]

FWIW, I think the middle picture (the round halo with the bigger stones) looks the most like they were designed to go together. But the cushion with the halo also looks nice. I'm not a fan of the first one.

 

[jaysonsmom]

Love the plain shank with Cushion Halo. Have contemplated resetting my ring into that look.

How about a beadset halo like this?

 

[headlight]

I like the plain shank with the cushion halo. I say this because unless you have a ring made custom to match your wedding band, the size of the stones and they way they are set won't match and I don't care for that look.
The plain shank doesn't compete with the band and lets the band make a statement of its own. I also like how a plain band allows one to actually appreciate the halo without having so much going on around it.
I like how the plain e-ring shank is similar in dimension to your wedding band. That looks like it was intentionally done that way from the beginning.
The only thing I would want to know is how well they fit together. Interestingly, it seems as though the round halo with the larger stones fits the most flush??? Does the plain band fit flush?

 

[Honeybasil]

I like the plain shank with the cushion halo. I say this because unless you have a ring made custom to match your wedding band, the size of the stones and they way they are set won't match and I don't care for that look.
The plain shank doesn't compete with the band and lets the band make a statement of its own. I also like how a plain band allows one to actually appreciate the halo without having so much going on around it.
I like how the plain e-ring shank is similar in dimension to your wedding band. That looks like it was intentionally done that way from the beginning.
The only thing I would want to know is how well they fit together. Interestingly, it seems as though the round halo with the larger stones fits the most flush??? Does the plain band fit flush?

I actually love the way the plain band fits with it. It fits flush and sits well above the band.

 

[headlight]

I actually love the way the plain band fits with it. It fits flush and sits well above the band.

I LOVE this!

 

[Honeybasil]

Love the plain shank with Cushion Halo. Have contemplated resetting my ring into that look.

How about a beadset halo like this?

Oh those are beautiful!!

 

[Honeybasil]

I LOVE this!

Me too! I love how it sits up like a solitaire. It makes the diamond really stand out. My current setting is too low for my wedding ring and is rubbing underneath.

 

[foxinsox]

I loved the round halo but the plain shank. I think the round halo stones were the 'right' size for the stone shown.

 

[Honeybasil]

I loved the round halo but the plain shank. I think the round halo stones were the 'right' size for the stone shown.

Any idea on the size of the halo diamonds? I’m getting a ring made, so I’m trying to figure out what to ask for! I’m attaching the drawing of the ring from the company.

 

[foxinsox]

No idea sorry but I would suggest getting a ruler out and measuring the width of the centre diamond and the width of the halo ones and working out what ratio of the central diamond the halo ones are rather than going for the specific size of those ones against an unknown size centre stone. i thought the ratio of halo stones was the most pleasing so you want to duplicate that.
I don't have a ruler at work with me so can't check it.

 

[Rose-gold-or-bust]

Plain shank! Otherwise the beautiful cushion gets lost