shape
carat
color
clarity

H color strong blue or J color med blue?

diamondsrgirlsbf2

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
7
Hello,
I'm new here. Trying learn about diamonds. I've done some research and picked these 2 diamonds. Still not sure which is better. If price is not an issue which would you pick?
Thank you!


1.

20200520_134835.jpg

3.03

J color/VS2/3ex/Med blue fluorescence

56/62.0/34.5/40.8/80/4

2.

Screenshot_20200520-134736_Internet.jpg

3.03

H color/SI1/3ex/Strong blue

56/62.4/36/40.6/75/3.5
 
Did you run these through the HCA calculator? I would likely pick #1 because of the 36 crown on #2, so I'd be a bit hesitant without an ASET/IS to confirm performance. Plus #2 is right on the cusp of too deep for my taste.
 
Did you run these through the HCA calculator? I would likely pick #1 because of the 36 crown on #2, so I'd be a bit hesitant without an ASET/IS to confirm performance. Plus #2 is right on the cusp of too deep for my taste.
Here's the HCA scores.
Unfortunately I wont be able to check with aset scope due to living overseas. This is pretty much all the info I have.

#1

Screenshot_20200520-141718_Internet.jpg

#2

Screenshot_20200520-131623_Internet.jpg
 
put them on hold ans send us the reports
 
put them on hold ans send us the reports

Unfortunately these are blue nile diamonds and was told they do not provide ASET/IS.

I actually saw another diamond and curious how 60/60 diamond is different from lets say #1 diamond I picked. If you'd kindly explain for a newbie it will be greatly appreciated.

Here's #3 diamond

It's h color also with strong blue and the rest of the info is on the 2nd pic.
Screenshot_20200521-145504_Internet.jpg
Screenshot_20200521-131633_Internet.jpg
Screenshot_20200521-131642_Internet.jpg
 
certs?
 
Just a personal opinion but I would not be buying a really expensive diamond without seeing all the light return images I could get! Have you looked at other vendors who do supply these? Can you ask Blue Nile?
 
Just a personal opinion but I would not be buying a really expensive diamond without seeing all the light return images I could get! Have you looked at other vendors who do supply these? Can you ask Blue Nile?

I have asked blue nile already. They told me they dont provide images. I haven't thought of that. I'll try!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top