H color strong blue or J color med blue?

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

Hello,
I'm new here. Trying learn about diamonds. I've done some research and picked these 2 diamonds. Still not sure which is better. If price is not an issue which would you pick?
Thank you!


1.



3.03

J color/VS2/3ex/Med blue fluorescence

56/62.0/34.5/40.8/80/4

2.



3.03

H color/SI1/3ex/Strong blue

56/62.4/36/40.6/75/3.5

 

[lovedogs]

Did you run these through the HCA calculator? I would likely pick #1 because of the 36 crown on #2, so I'd be a bit hesitant without an ASET/IS to confirm performance. Plus #2 is right on the cusp of too deep for my taste.

 

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

Did you run these through the HCA calculator? I would likely pick #1 because of the 36 crown on #2, so I'd be a bit hesitant without an ASET/IS to confirm performance. Plus #2 is right on the cusp of too deep for my taste.

Here's the HCA scores.
Unfortunately I wont be able to check with aset scope due to living overseas. This is pretty much all the info I have.

#1



#2

 

[lovedogs]

I would still go with #1

 

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

I would still go with #1

Thanks for your advice!

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

put them on hold ans send us the reports

 

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

put them on hold ans send us the reports

Unfortunately these are blue nile diamonds and was told they do not provide ASET/IS.

I actually saw another diamond and curious how 60/60 diamond is different from lets say #1 diamond I picked. If you'd kindly explain for a newbie it will be greatly appreciated.

Here's #3 diamond

It's h color also with strong blue and the rest of the info is on the 2nd pic.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

certs?

 

[Snowdrop13]

Just a personal opinion but I would not be buying a really expensive diamond without seeing all the light return images I could get! Have you looked at other vendors who do supply these? Can you ask Blue Nile?

 

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

certs?

certs?

Thank you for taking your time to look

#1

https://www.bluenile.com/jp/en/diamond-details/LD134026

#2

3.03-Carat Round Cut Diamond | Blue Nile

www.bluenile.com

#3

3.51-Carat Round Cut Diamond | Blue Nile

www.bluenile.com

 

[diamondsrgirlsbf2]

Just a personal opinion but I would not be buying a really expensive diamond without seeing all the light return images I could get! Have you looked at other vendors who do supply these? Can you ask Blue Nile?

I have asked blue nile already. They told me they dont provide images. I haven't thought of that. I'll try!