Ugh, I'm boring. I don't know what fancy setting I want yet so I ordered the plain 2mm knife edge in platinum for now.
https://www.tiffany.com/jewelry/rings/tiffany-wedding-band-GRP00379/
I thought it would be fun to have a Tiffany wedding band. However, the 6 prong head of my e-ring is platinum from Whiteflash but the shank is 14k white gold from Blue Nile. I could get a matching 14k knife edge band from Blue Nile for an exact match but I don't want to have to replate TWO rings. Do you think the platinum will clash with the 14k white gold e-ring shank?
BN knife edge available in 14k white gold or platinum.
https://www.bluenile.com/knife-edge-wedding-band-platinum_34241
What a mishmosh engagement set!
Rose gold pave
This little guy wants to play, too!
I have a soft spot for rose gold, too, @Morenita21! I love how it pairs well with both yellow and white metals.There’s just something beautiful about rose gold with diamonds and a Solitaire
Tiffany knife edge band is here! What do y’all think? Feels nice on the hand. Keeper or should I get the Blue Nile knife edge for a “perfect match” width and height-wise? The BN one won’t sit perfectly flush either bc of the e-ring’s donut. The Tiffany band sits lower than the ACA solitaire which is totally stealing the show. 
Hope this pic caught the height discrepancy (and some arrows!). The width and “knifeyness” is pretty spot on, tho!
When the band has diamonds, then I find the metal color differences tolerable.
I think so. I would get the platinum version tho if I went to BN.
Thank you, @MissGotRocks! You think I should keep the Tiffany band instead of the exact BN match (actually the e-ring is wg and I would get the plat if I get the one from BN)? Will likely treasure Tiffany band in the future more and who knows what my e-ring will be later.
Thank you, @MissGotRocks! You think I should keep the Tiffany band instead of the exact BN match (actually the e-ring is wg and I would get the plat if I get the one from BN)? Will likely treasure Tiffany band in the future more and who knows what my e-ring will be later.
P.S. I just love the aqua blues reflecting from the cell phone case!
If I really needed to match the set, I'd rather work from the Tiffany band than the BN band. I just think that the Tiffany bands are honed to perfection and are something to have for a lifetime. May be a bit sappy - but that's just me! Besides, I love your story - from a harrowing blender nightmare to a gorgeous, iconic set - and I love happy endings!!
...and looks divine in white, yellow and rose!
Aw shucks, thank you for your kind words and for taking the time to share your experiences with knife edge rings, @KristyDarling! I, too, appreciate a plain band with a solitaire. Diamond and more ornate bands are fun but a plain solitaire set is simply elegant!I think your new band is beautiful!! To my eyes, the difference in width is negligible. Not too surprising coming from me since my knife edge band and my knife-edge solitaire are from different makers and are NOT the same width (the width difference is about the same as yours, actually), and it does not bother me at all. The difference is so slight and I'm never "looking" for it. In real life, you'd have to scrutinize the rings pretty carefully to notice the tiny bit of width difference. That said, if it bothers you, then I would suggest giving the BN version a try.
As for whether I'd still go Tiffany with the band, my answer is not necessarily. At the time, I had tried 3 other knife edge bands from random jewelers (e-weddingbands, local jewelers, etc.) and they just looked clunky and angular and kinda cheapish....whereas Tiffany's version was so elegant, sleek, and just looked like QUALITY, so I splurged. But, I recently saw a thread by @moneymeister who bought a knife-edge from Ritani, which looks like a dead-ringer for my Tiffany band and is the same width as well, so I decided to give it a shot. At $208 incl. tax, it was a steal compared to what I paid for the Tiffany years ago. The band will arrive next Monday.
BTW, I agree with @MissGotRocks that your set stands on its own. That floaty giant beautiful diamond looks AMAZING with just the knife edge band!!!
Loving this thread! Everyone seems to be covering all bases, so I haven't commented thus far, but count me as one more who values a perfect match; the design is so simple and clean, any deviation will stick out a mile, which would send me nuts.
And I agree; stay with BN for the bands, then add a Tiffany diamond anni or eternity band for those times you want a little more bling. Tho it's hard to conceive wanting more bling with that stunner you already have on your finger!!
300x240.png)
