Mara
Super_Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Oct 30, 2002
- Messages
- 31,003
----------------
On 9/20/2003 9:17:45 PM mrs.larson wrote:
I am also studying to get my Graduate Gemologist degree with GIA. From what I've learned through the school and also from my own experiences, I would never recommend buying a diamond online. You might get the same size diamond online for a lot cheaper, but you will be sacrificing color and clarity.
--This statement is so blatantly untrue I don't even know where to begin--maybe you should really do your own research which you obviously have not done. As with any venue, whether online or offline, there are going to be good and bad experiences. Like offline, there can be good and bad jewelers and vendors. But to classify all online diamonds as inferior and say that one would have to 'sacrifice' color and clarity is totally absurd. I dare you to price one of the unbranded or even branded for that matter H&A's to half of what 'reputable' jewelry stores offer online and tell me that they don't don't outshine in CUT and QUALITY and probably for LESS money. The inane, unfounded statement you made is what furthers the public's fear of online purchasing and keeps people in the dark. As an ardent online purchaser (of many things, even jewelry), I (like most people) know that as with any big purchase, you have to shop smart and be educated. If you have done your homework, no one is going to throw the wool over your eyes. If a consumer is stupid, they will be stupid offline AND online...but if they are educated, they will walk into an offline store, quiz the vendor for all they are worth, do the same online..and then make their own educated decision.
From my own experiences..we have not purchased a diamond online (yet) but we did alot of offline and online shopping. I walked into a reputed jeweler and was shown a 1.5c H SI for $17000. No info about cut and sorry but the GIA cert doesn't say jack about the 'cut' as you should know if you are getting your GIA degree. Table and depth is the minimum that one should know--where are the angles? Anyway I digress. A well cut 1.5 H SI1 online with a branded H&A cut or similar would most likely be around $14000 or less! With more paperwork and security shown from some of the online vendors than I saw in visiting MANY offline jewelry stores. We went with an offline purchase because we knew the jeweler and he jumped through hoops to get us what we wanted AND matched internet pricing. But our next purchase WILL be online from a reputed vendor.
When you buy a diamond form Derco, they show you the GIA report and also let you view the diamond under a loupe (magnifier), so you can see exactly what inclusions it has (or doesn't have When you buy online, you cannot see the diamond's inclusions. Even if the picture looks nice and sparkly, remember that it can be doctored and that there are a lot of scam artists selling *Certified* diamonds, but you're really getting a CZ and a fake or copied certificate.
--Great that Derco actually shows you the GIA report. Does this mean anything other than that is what they should be doing? What everyone should be doing? Should we give a prize for doing the absolute mininum? It always blows me away to hear people say that 'well they showed me the GIA report...'...thats the least of what they should do. There should be a Sarin report with it and if you are buying online, alot more information than just that. Anyway...I digress. Yes when you buy online you can't see the diamond's inclusions obviously, but there are plenty of vendors who magnify those inclusions and then show them virtually so that the customer does get a sense of where they are. There is also the IdealScope images which many offline jewelers would not have. Also many vendors have no problem sending the stone off for independent appraisal before purchase and there the customer can usually see the stone in person if the appraiser is local to them. Again--all of this showing that the customer needs to be smart and savvy, the pressure is on them. YES there are scam artists out there, AS WITH ANYTHING you buy, you have to be smart. Too many people are not smart and then throw thousands of dollars at a vendor, whether its online at some random shop or eBay auction, or offline at some jeweler in NYC who had alot of stones but nothing else. Those people will get taken for a ride whether online or offline.
If it is a real diamond, it will probably be very yellow colored and have spots, cracks, chips, or other things that will make it dull and not white, clear and sparkly as the diamonds you can see for yourself in person.
--Shop on eBay much?? Again--the consumer needs to be educated on color, clarity and cut..only the ignorant would buy what you just noted above, whether online or offline. Education is the key here. Anyone can be taken for a ride on any purchase. As for what you see with your eyes...we get plenty of people here on this forum who in the shining store lights thought tthat their diamond was clear and sparkly. Guess what? They get it home and realize the cut is quite bad and it looks like crap. So then they return it. Not all diamonds you see in person are going to be 'clear and sparkly' as you put it. Another perpetuated myth!
The scariest part of your post here mrs.larson is that you are studying to become a GIA graduate. Someday quite soon you will be working in a local jewelry store to me (I'm in San Jose) and you will be mistakenly perpetuating fear and myths about online shopping. You will drive sales away from online into offline stores, and you will probably sell some pretty mediocre stones to unsuspecting customers if you trust that GIA's cert is all you will need to make that sale with a customer. Hang around the forums a little and I bet you will really start to get your education on diamonds--for free even. I have learned more here than I bet GIA could have taught me..I took the first course and while it was interesting...it was nothing I hadn't learned in my first 2 months on this forum. Stick around and broaden your mind.![]()