Would you say 400 dollars is a fair price for this aquamarine ?

[Lunean]

Hey,

I've been looking for an aquamarine for some time. Here is a 12 carats one from Nigeria with good dimensions (15.400 x 15.300 x 10.400 mm). I know deeper blue aquas are more highly valued and that is has a window but I actually like this lighter color. I trust the vendor from whom I already bought, my only questions are both the price (never bought aquamarines) and the brown stain you can see on the first pic. Any opinion would be highly appreciated

 

[Autumn in New England]

Absolutely... I've seen the super pale material go for more than that (only $33/carat). This is mid-range saturation to me. Very pretty. Can you see the brown stain face-up?

 

[mellowyellowgirl]

Bargain!!!!

Can you see the stain face up and if yes, does that bother you?

 

[T L]

That brown looks like a facet reflecting something brown. I don’t think it’s inherent to the stone. $400 is a fair price.

 

[Lunean]

Bargain!!!!

Can you see the stain face up and if yes, does that bother you?

Thanks for your replies guys! I don't see the stain on the video from the top so I guess it can be set hiding it! I think i'll go for it for a very simple pendent

 

[PrecisionGem]

That brown looks like a facet reflecting something brown. I don’t think it’s inherent to the stone. $400 is a fair price.

I would bet that TL is 100% correct on this. In photos facets will always pick up some other color near by. If it was in the stone, it wouldn't show on only the surface of one facet.

 

[fredflintstone]

Hey,

I've been looking for an aquamarine for some time. Here is a 12 carats one from Nigeria with good dimensions (15.400 x 15.300 x 10.400 mm). I know deeper blue aquas are more highly valued and that is has a window but I actually like this lighter color. I trust the vendor from whom I already bought, my only questions are both the price (never bought aquamarines) and the brown stain you can see on the first pic. Any opinion would be highly appreciated

Looks nice and yes, the brown is a reflection off the facet. It is the price. Seems too good to be true $400 for a 12 carat Aqua of this saturation. I'd be very wary unless you know of other people who have bought from this vendor whomever it may be. I bet the stone is quite a bit paler in person. Beware of light blue Topaz masquerading as Aqua too.

 

[fredflintstone]

I googled the pictures. The price I seen was $1499.00. Which sounds about right. Still a good deal. I've seen them for much more this color and this size.