As a surprise, I am purchasing a diamond for my wife for our anniversary. I have found two diamonds that seem very similiar in all aspects except price and I am trying to understand what additional factors cause the price difference. Also, are these prices reasonable for the diamonds described below? Thanks.
Diamond 1 - $4,823
1.00 Carats
Ideal cut
H color
VS2 clarity
GIA certified
measurements are 6.53-6.55x3.96
Depth 60.6%
Table 54%
Girdle is thin to medium
no culet or flouresence
polish and symmetry are both excellent
Diamond 2 - $5,613
all factors the same except
measurements are 6.53-6.54x3.95
Depth 60.4%
Table 56%
Girdle is medium
Diamond 1 - $4,823
1.00 Carats
Ideal cut
H color
VS2 clarity
GIA certified
measurements are 6.53-6.55x3.96
Depth 60.6%
Table 54%
Girdle is thin to medium
no culet or flouresence
polish and symmetry are both excellent
Diamond 2 - $5,613
all factors the same except
measurements are 6.53-6.54x3.95
Depth 60.4%
Table 56%
Girdle is medium