which stone would u choose?

[kyon]

Hello guys, I hope u can help with these few stones. Which one would u prefer?
Carat 1.153 1.024 1.033
Color H E G
Clarity SI1 SI1 VS2
Measurements 6.82-6.83 x 4.12 6.47-6.51x4.00 6.57-6.59 x 3.97
Table % 55 55 56
Depth % 60.3 61.6 60.3
Polish Ideal Ideal Ideal
Symmetry Ideal Ideal Ideal
Girdle 0.9%-1.5% Thin to Medium Facet 1.0-1.7 0.9%-1.4% Thin to Medium Facet
Culet Pointed Pointed Pointed
Fluorescence Inert Inert Inert
Pardon my format above hope u can read, HCA scores 1.3 1.3 1.5 respectively. Brilliantscope results are not avail. As u can see, i''m not v good with this, hope u can tell me which one and why u prefer. Thank u.

 

[Richard Sherwood]

VERY tough choice. All appear to be great stones. It would be helpful to have the crown & pavilion angles/heights for a more accurate judgement. How did you manage to get the HCA scores if you don't have those measurements?

That said, if the cuts are good and price is no object, I would go with the higher color stones, either the E or the G. Between those two I personally would probably go with the larger diameter and "cleaner" VS2.

G/VS2 with a great cut. A killer combination.

 

[kyon]

Dep Tbl Crn Pav
1.153 H SI1 60.3 55 34.9° 40.8°

1.024 E SI1 61.6 55 34.9° 40.8°

1.033 G VS2 60.3 56 34.8° 40.8°
oops, i forget to put in the above...