which one do you think is better? Thank you

[IMIM]

Hi everyone! I'm new here obviously.
I've been looking around and learning about diamonds and rings
Hopefully, you guys can provide some feedback regarding the performance 3 of diamonds that I'm considering purchasing.I am most interested in the light performance of the diamond.
which one do you think is better? Thank you very much~

DIAMOND1
Colour G VS2
3EX GIA
Depth 62.1 , table56, crown angle 34.5, pavilion angle40.8; culet none
Fluoresence none
Girdle Slightly thick
US $35XX





DIAMOND2
Colour H VS2
3 Ideal AGS
Depth 62.7 , table54.8, crown angle 34, pavilion angle40.9; culet pointed
Fluoresence Negligible
thin to medium faceted
US $33XX





DIAMOND 3
Colour H SI1
3 Ideal AGS
Depth 61.6 , table56.2, crown angle 34.8, pavilion angle40.7; culet Pointed
Fluoresence Negligible
thin to slightly thick faceted
us$33xx

 

[tyty333]

These are all excellent stones. I think the light performance on all of them would be very nice and not sure you could
really tell much difference. You might call WF and have them evaluate them side by side and have them tell you
what they see. I did notice that diamond 1 has thinner arrows. Do you prefer fatter or thinner arrows?

Have you looked at the dimensions on the stones? Some are deeper then others. Can you provide the dimensions.
That would help narrow it down for me.

 

[IMIM]

THANKS tyty333 of notice ~

WF told me , they saw both diamonds are eye-clean and both are bright and beautiful. Visually they are the same
and they recommended take the Diamond 1 because it is a G and a better value.
Here link them side by side, and I found the diamond1 light performance is "Not available".
Which are better to buy thicker arrows or thinner arrows diamond?
thanks!!!
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/compare.aspx?idnos=3025056%2c3061811

 

[move1986]

personally i like diamond 2 better with the H color

 

[pmsomani]

I liked third diamond for its highly symmetrical optical performance. And its light return is also expected good as per SET image.

 

[metatrix]

I am by no means an expert, so take the following with a grain of salt...

I would go with either stone 1 or stone 2. I wouldn't get stone 3 because of those two big spots of green on the girdle at 11 o'clock and 2 o'clock (due to uneven girdle indexing...although all three stones look like they have slightly painted girdles to me...but not enough to get dinged by GIA for it).

Stone 1 has more and bigger/darker hotspots between the arrow heads (under the star facets). If I'm not mistaken, this will mean more fire, particularly more pinflash. It also, imo, has the nicest and most symmetrical contrast pattern of the three. On the other hand, it looks like there are some black inclusions near the top, and the slightly thick girdle means that it doesn't have the best spread. Also, some of those arrowheads are looking slightly greenish, although I'm not sure if that's real or just an illusion/due to the photography.

Stone 2 looks to have thicker arrows which is great if you like bold flashes. But it has tiny hotspots, which would mean less of that small pinfire/scintillation. I like that it has a thin to medium girdle -- better spread!

I'm unsure as to which stone has better optical symmetry. Stone 2 looks to have a more symmetrical ASET, but stone 1 looks to have better symmetry in the actual photo of the diamond...