Which one: A or B?

[snoopy916]

A

 

[snoopy916]

B

 

[snoopy916]

Thoughts?

 

[tyty333]

It would be nice to have a hearts image on B to see what is going on between 6 and 7 oclock.

Are these stones at the same vendor by any chance? If so, can they do a side by side comparison for you? Tell you what they
see in each stone?

Neither of them are perfect but A looks decent for what it is (non H&A). B doesnt look bad either (from the info I have) but would
like to see a hearts image to know whats going on. Is that black showing up in real life while all the other facets under the
table are reflecting light like they should? That would drive me nuts.

Can you post any real images of the stones?

 

[snoopy916]

A

B

 

[flyingpig]

I say they are about equal.
None has any detrimental light leakage. The contrast patterns are not symmetrical in both diamond. I would go with B for more well defined contrast pattern and less light leakage. But close...

Above all, pricing needs to be attractive for such stones. Do you have gia nunbers?

 

[snoopy916]

They are for earrings. HCA score for both under 2. Price is $700 for each. Thank you for your help!

 

[maccers]

Those seem like good choices for earrings.

I'm confused why you're asking A or B? Do you have another stone picked out already?

 

[flyingpig]

I think they are both decent for earrings.
I would do something like J/I SI under $500 for each, and save $400.

 

[snoopy916]

Those seem like good choices for earrings.

I'm confused why you're asking A or B? Do you have another stone picked out already?

Yeah i already have another one picked. Just trying to decide which one is better.

 

[snoopy916]

I decided on A, thank you all for your help.