Which is the better deal?

[22inchdenali]

I am seriously looking at purchasing a diamond engagement ring and have been doing some research online. The setting I want is at mondera.com, so I have been looking for diamonds through them as well. I would like a round, 1 carat diamond (or close to it) and to stay under $6K. After some extensive research, I have come up with the following 3 diamonds. Please let me know which one you believe to be the best buy and why. Thanks!

Diamond #1 ($5,531)
GIA Lab
1.00 Carats
Premium Cut
G Color
SI1 Clarity
6.41-6.47x3.97mm
Depth 61.6%
Table 59%
Medium to Slighty Thick Girdle
No Cutlet
Very Good Polish
Very Good Symmetry
No Flourescence

Diamond #2 ($5,850)
GIA Lab
1.00 Carats
Very Good Cut
E Color
VS2 Clarity
6.39-6.49x3.86mm
Depth 59.9%
Table 62%
Thin Girdle
No Cutlet
Good Polish
Good Symmetry
No Flourescence

Diamond #3 ($5,330)
AGS Lab
.95 Carats
Ideal Cut
G Color
VS2 Clarity
6.25-6.28x3.92mm
Depth 62.6%
Table 57%
Thin to Medium Girdle
Very Small Cutlet
Ideal Polish
Ideal Symmetry
Ideal AGS Cut
No Flourescence

 

[lawmax]

Ask for Sarin reports on the stones you are interested in and post the information here.

 

[22inchdenali]

I am inquiring about the Sarin reports and will post them as soon as I can, but in the meantime at first glance, what are your first inclinations?

Thanks.

 

[lawmax]

My first inclination would be #3, but it looks deep. I'd want to see the Sarin report on it.