Which is a better deal?

[K]

1.51 ct
7.37 - 7.41 X 4.56mm
61.7 % depth
56% table
thin to med. facet
no culet
EX Polish & Symmetry
SI1, G
No fluour. Nothing in comments. One worry is a crystal close to 6 o clock which looks like it is on table (center piece) and a feather at the end (will that feather turn into something larger when set?)

OGI has a HCA score of 2.6
with 35.1 degree crown angle
41.1 degree pavillion angle
and .6 culet (using OGI table and depth %)

$9823



And the other>>>>>>>>
From GIA
1.53 ct
7.45 - 7.49 X 4.56mm
61. % depth
56% table
thin to med. facet
no culet
EX Polish & Symmetry
SI1, G
No fluour. Comments = Clouds not shown. Surface graining is not shown.

Has a HCA score of .8
with 34.7 degree crown angle
40.7 degree pavillion angle
and no culet information (using table and depth % from GIA cert)The thing is, I am not sure if it is a Sarin (though said they use Sarin on their Site)

~$9937

Please help. Thanks

 

[lawmax]

By the numbers only, I'm liking number 2 better. You need to see it or have an independent appraiser see it to check out those inclusions.

 

[K]

SO, how does clouds and surface graniness affect the stone?

 

[lawmax]

We'll wait for an expert to show up. I think that it is possible for the clouds to be an issue, but not always.