Which Diamond?

[cleve-rocks]

I have been slightly a pain, but I swear I am getting very close to ordering a stone....
These 2 stones are almost EXACTLY the same price... I am concerned with Cut, Size, Clarity, Color in that order.
I can''t get idealscope images...

1)
1.4c
I color
SI1
60.6 depth
56 table
34 crown angle
41 pavilion angle
7.17 x 7.26 x 4.37

2)
1.5
J color
VS2
61.7 depth
57 table
35 crown angle
40.8 pavilion angle
7.22 x 7.28 x 4.47


These stones spread almost exactly the same, but stone 1 is shallower. I think they trade off color for clarity...
Stone 1 scored a 1.0 on the HCA and Stone 2 scored a 2.0
They are both GIA.

By this information, can you choose one?

 

[Lorelei]

From the info given I would be most interested in the first but I would really like to see Idealscope or ASET images for each in order to determine which is the best one - and especially I would want IS for the second....The vendor won't supply these images I take it?

 

[Ellen]

Could you possibly get a Sarin report for them?

 

[cleve-rocks]

They are common stones from WF, so not in house stones. The rep from WF said they are request info, but that most of their suppliers for these stones don''t supply images.

Anyone have experience with the "3rd" grade of "common" stones from WF?