SgrPlum12
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2008
- Messages
- 93
Hi everyone. My boyfriend and I are currently trying to decide between two very similar diamonds. They are the same size, cut and clarity. The major difference is that one is a J and one is an I color.
We can definitely see the difference when viewing them on their sides next to each other. The price difference is pretty significant too. The I costs 30% more than the J. I want my boyfriend to get the J, since I think it will look white when not being compared to another diamond. He is not convinced and thinks that it looks too yellow.
Here are the comparison images. know that we can return the J if we aren't happy with it in person, but we'd like to avoid all that if possible.
Does anyone have any words of wisdom to help us with this decision? Anyone own a J diamond that they can vouch looks white? Or does it have noticeable yellow to it and you'd recommend going to the I color instead?
Thanks!
We can definitely see the difference when viewing them on their sides next to each other. The price difference is pretty significant too. The I costs 30% more than the J. I want my boyfriend to get the J, since I think it will look white when not being compared to another diamond. He is not convinced and thinks that it looks too yellow.
Here are the comparison images. know that we can return the J if we aren't happy with it in person, but we'd like to avoid all that if possible.
Does anyone have any words of wisdom to help us with this decision? Anyone own a J diamond that they can vouch looks white? Or does it have noticeable yellow to it and you'd recommend going to the I color instead?
Thanks!