Which diamond is a better value?

[fraggle30]

Hello all!! I posted a question in the forum a couple of day's ago and asked which diamond was a better deal between the ones listed below. A couple of people responded saying they could not give me their opinion without more information on the diamonds so I posted more info the EGL specks . So my question is which diamond is the better value in your opinion? Thanks so much any advice or info would be awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

both are EGL graded

This stone is very nice but I did notice a carbon spot on the diamond that if you looked at it closely even an untrailed eye could notice.
This diamond is 6,600

Stone 29805901D
Weight 2.02 CT
Shape RECT. MOD. BRILL.
Color H
Clarity SI2
Measurements 7.7 x 6.58 x 4.89 mm
Depth 74.3%
Table 85%
Crown 5.2%
Pavilion 64.6%
Crown Angle 37.3°
Pavilion Angle 59.3°
Girdle VERY THIN TO SL. THICK POLISHED
Polish GOOD
Symmetry GOOD
Fluorescence NONE
Culet NONE
Cut Grade N/A

This second stone is nice, if you look closely you could see a couple of feathers but the cut is so good it's hard to see the feathers unless you look closely I'm no expert but thats what I thought. This diamond is 7,000

Stone 901481701D
Weight 2.16 CT
Shape RECT. MOD. BRILLIANT
Color H
Clarity SI3
Measurements 7.99 x 6.87 x 4.56 mm
Depth 70.7%
Table 74.2%
Crown 8.2%
Pavilion 60.3%
Crown Angle 37.1°
Pavilion Angle 39.3°
Girdle VERY THIN TO THICK POLISHED
Polish VERY GOOD
Symmetry VERY GOOD
Fluorescence N/A
Culet N/A
Cut Grade N/A

 

[purplesilk]

Since your diamonds are not round, HCA cannot be applied.
I think you should provide for ASET pictures, so we can help you to judge which one is the best performer.

Experts...anyone aroud here?

 

[denverappraiser]

You're putting a lot of confidence in the clarity and color grades. The differences between SI2/I1 and H/I/J are hugely important topics and you might consider some research into the various labs that offer this service. This is a common topic of conversation in the forum here and it applies directlly to your question.