I am by no means an expert on cushions or fancy stones, but I can see a fair amount of light leakage under the table. Also, from reading other posts, I believe you want to see a lot more red than green in the ASET images. There's a lot of green in the images you have…..
Hoping someone who knows more will chime in for you.
both these cushions are terrible! Stay away and work with a vendor who can find you an amazing cushion within your price range.
What is your budget and what size are you looking for?