Sorry not a fan of the "wave", so I couldn't say. I would rather a little space and have a right hand ring if I wanted, or to wear it alone with no odd appearances.
I think Vatche made that wave specifically for the X-Prong, so it should fit well if that's what it nicest to you...
Hey! Aneelcon just got a wave band to go along with her e-ring. Check this out:
https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/my-new-sparklies.14125/
(Sorry, I don't know how to create a link! I hope that works, if not it's the thread in Show Me the Ring titled "My New Sparklies" by aneelcon)
I really prefer when the wedding band sits flush against the e-ring. I know there are people who like having that gap, but I'm not one of them. If the low setting is creating a gap, the wave ring might be a great alternative to get those rings to sit flush.
I love the X prong e-rings...but never thought about the wedding band fitting with it, so I am glad you brought it up.
I would think that there will be some occasions where you may want to wear just the wedding band and the wave may look odd alone.
But, I have only seen the wave ring with an e-ring attached, so its hard to say.
Ha ha! Diagnolman, you're too funny! I didn't realize that you haven't even bought the ring or proposed yet. You deserve some kudos for thinking that far ahead. I think people get so caught up in just the e-ring that they forget they'll have to choose a wedding ring to go along with it. Then, they get stuck with an e-ring that is so difficult to match to any ring. So, good for you for thinking ahead!
I actually think the wave ring looks cool alone too. I don't know, that little bump is different from the ordinary straight band. I like it!
Can't stand wave bands, myself. They make the wedding ring look like an afterthought--whereas to me, the wedding ring is the important ring, since it symbolizes the marriage. And I like to be able to wear my wedding band alone.
I agree with Glitterata. The wave ring looks like an afterthought.
And, will it spin?
That would look stupid, too.
I'd really like to get matching wedding bands with my (to be) husband, but I doubt if we'll be able to agree (he won't want to wear an eternity band...)
1. The Wave band is sorta thinking ahead for those who like flush fit bands, but really want a lower set diamond too.
2. However, the odd-ness of the wave band by itself has to be reconciled by the wearer. If you can't, then the point is moot.
There's this other band I saw... I think it only really works with standard Tiffany style 4 and 6 prong e-rings. They have little notches cut out of the wedding band to accommodate for the prong arms. Lemme find a pic.
The jury's still out for me tho... I'll have to show the GF the options once she says, "Yes." (If she says yes!)
Here's a link to GOG's site. It's kinda hard to see on some, but you get the idea. Flush fit bands, but the notches accommodate the prongs. Similarly, you could spin the ring around if you're not wearing the e-ring.
Sorry I don't have a picture of the setting so you can see, the ring we chose is not the Vatche x-prong after all. It looks a lot like it, but it's made by Alfred Butler. I did a web search, but no info... which seemed a little weird. Anyway, BF had actually brought a picture of the Vatche x-prong off the web and we compared the two. The Alfred Butler ring does not require the wave band - it is designed straighter and doesn't really flare out slightly as the x-prong does.
I am so glad I read these threads because it had never occurred to me to try on wedding bands with the e-ring.
The first thing I tried on was just as wide as the e-ring and it felt awful & looked awful.
So we actually pulled back and reconsidered settings.
Eventually I was really in love with the Alfred Butler ring and found that a very slender wedding band (2-3 mm) gave me the look & the comfort I was after.
I'm still not sure about an eternity band or a plain band because when you get decent sized stones on the eternity band it just starts getting bulky (for my comfort, anyway)
Ahhh such fun decisions. We have over a year to figure out the wedding bands but it's nice to know what the options are.
I searched the web and found that there is an Alfred Butler Inc. that will an exhibitor at the JA New York Summer Show on July 25-28, 2004 (at booth 2437).
Maybe this is someone who only trades with B&M ? I can't find an presence on the internet.
The salesman at Smyth (a big jewelry store in Maryland) said the ring would be made to fit my stone and the prongs are pulled by hand into the trellis shape. He told us to expect a wait of about 4 weeks.
The price was right in line with Vatche, which is partly why I just assumed it was the x-prong.
Yeah, I think that's it! The prongs definitely look the way I remember them.
I wish they showed more angles so you can see it from the side and the top.
This is turning into a question for David Emslie or Griffin.
I am just curious as to how these vendors work. Maybe Alfred Butler, Inc. purposely sells only to their business partners.
Maybe they want you to go to the B&M store to get their stuff? hmm who knows.
I just want to say that Smyth gave us a great deal and the customer service has been awesome. They were more than willing to give Sarin reports on stones and fit into the budget pretty quickly once we got serious.
No champagne, but they did give me a Diet Coke!!
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.