Urgently need help with these 0.5ct F VVS2

[cfdmaybe]

I need to put a ring on her. We just got done with Covid. I had previously posted regarding this setting and the stones I picked are now updated.
Setting: Size 6

Cheri 3 Stone Diamond Engagement Ring | 3631

Add a touch of elegance with the Cheri 3 Stone Diamond Engagement Ring. Discover this captivating ring at Whiteflash and let your love story unfold. | 3631

www.whiteflash.com

Would you help me pick between the two? The price savings is about $150. The ASET images concern me. Amateur 1st buyer here. I’m aware of recommended center stone size for this ring. It’s a semi-custom. Side stones are 0.1ct each.

0.571 ct F VVS2 (5.35x5.37x3.28 )
0.596 ct F VVS2(5.38x5.42x3.33)

 

[lovedogs]

I need to put a ring on her. We just got done with Covid. I had previously posted regarding this setting and the stones I picked are now updated.
Setting: Size 6

Cheri 3 Stone Diamond Engagement Ring | 3631

Add a touch of elegance with the Cheri 3 Stone Diamond Engagement Ring. Discover this captivating ring at Whiteflash and let your love story unfold. | 3631

www.whiteflash.com

Would you help me pick between the two? The price savings is about $150. The ASET images concern me. Amateur 1st buyer here. I’m aware of recommended center stone size for this ring. It’s a semi-custom. Side stones are 0.1ct each.

0.571 ct F VVS2 (5.35x5.37x3.28 )
0.596 ct F VVS2(5.38x5.42x3.33)

Both will be beautiful, but I prefer the .57 personally. You definitely don't need such high clarity, and going lower could get you more size. But of course up to you and your gf

 

[kb1gra]

I prefer the 0.57, but can I make a suggestion?

There's a really nice 0.612 G/VS2 ACA at very nearly the same price.