Since it was advertised as unheated, I might spring for an AGL gem brief. I have no idea how pricing for cabochons compares to that for faceted stones but I'm interested to learn!
Those are beautiful. I love the colours. I'm curious about the star - does it show up in normal light conditions or only with a bright light shining on it? I don't know how these things are supposed to behave irl and I'm curious.
About pricing, of course a cab is worth less because usually included crystals are cabbed, but I think if they have good colour, are big and untreated like yours they can still have a fair pricetag, but are still worth much less than a clean faceted gem of the same quality.
Love that gorgeous blue of the cab - is the cab transparent? Also love the star - its so nice to see round stars, as its so much more common to see ovals. Lovely stones.
Before discovering PS I was never really a cab fan but they are seriously growing on me. Both of yours are beautiful, I'm really drawn to the grey star, lovely colour!